I wasn't much a fan of the original Shining novel. It's really more of a memoir of Stephen King and his dependencies on drugs, coupled with his emotional shortcomings when dealing with his children. Fine, sure, whatever. The problem with this miniseries is it takes the established concepts of the novel and throws them completely away, substituting them with a picture of idealistic, one-dimensional characters and predictable horror clichés.
The biggest problem I have with this film is Jack Torrance. First, I feel he was badly miscast. I've always felt Jack should immediately seem strange; like someone you get a bad feeling over and want to stay away from. This fits in line with the character because of his history of alcohol abuse and his feelings towards his son, Danny. I never get that feeling. Half the movie you have nice guy Jack and suddenly he becomes a homicidal maniac. There's no fleshing out of his descent into madness. There's no context. He's nice and then evil. And furthermore, why is Jack this picture of an idealistic father? The scene with the entire family rolling in the snow and laughing is a complete bastardization of the character that it makes the film nearly unbearable to finish.
Wendy is another big problem. While she fits more in line with what King originally intended in his novel, she also falls flat. None of the actors fit right in their respective rolls. They just seem to be characters King threw in because he thought they looked the part. Again, Kubrick's vision of Wendy fell more in line with my original vision of Wendy--helpless, scared, weak, and needy. Shelly Duvall perfectly captured that.
The one bright spot in this miniseries is the depth of detail one gets about the Overlook Hotel and the background. But for all the other faults and tired predictability of conventional horror, the miniseries pales in comparison to Kubrick's vision.
2/10
The biggest problem I have with this film is Jack Torrance. First, I feel he was badly miscast. I've always felt Jack should immediately seem strange; like someone you get a bad feeling over and want to stay away from. This fits in line with the character because of his history of alcohol abuse and his feelings towards his son, Danny. I never get that feeling. Half the movie you have nice guy Jack and suddenly he becomes a homicidal maniac. There's no fleshing out of his descent into madness. There's no context. He's nice and then evil. And furthermore, why is Jack this picture of an idealistic father? The scene with the entire family rolling in the snow and laughing is a complete bastardization of the character that it makes the film nearly unbearable to finish.
Wendy is another big problem. While she fits more in line with what King originally intended in his novel, she also falls flat. None of the actors fit right in their respective rolls. They just seem to be characters King threw in because he thought they looked the part. Again, Kubrick's vision of Wendy fell more in line with my original vision of Wendy--helpless, scared, weak, and needy. Shelly Duvall perfectly captured that.
The one bright spot in this miniseries is the depth of detail one gets about the Overlook Hotel and the background. But for all the other faults and tired predictability of conventional horror, the miniseries pales in comparison to Kubrick's vision.
2/10
Tell Your Friends