Caveat (2020) Poster

(2020)

User Reviews

Review this title
120 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
5/10
Style over story
Movi3DO15 September 2021
Will you go to this sketchy and clearly dangerous place and babysit a weirdo child? Nope - FIN

A haunted house horror on Shudder. This movie was less than an hour and a half, but man it was slow and boring for the first hour and 10 minutes. It's atmospheric, but not as creepy as it intended to. I'll admit, the usage of background noise was quite effective in some scenes. Then, the horror really become significant at the end. The eyes were used to great extent that kept me on the edge.

My biggest problem was that this movie felt like testing horror and not about making a coherent story. Lots of things felt random and pointless.

Overall, the editing for horror was pretty good, but the story was nonsense. 5/10.
22 out of 24 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Starts off very strong. Then just meanders to an ending.
Otkon19 June 2021
Sad too. Because I was really enjoying the rabbit stuff. And the harness thing. And the Memento-style whodunit aspect. But it seemed to reveal all its tricks way too early and the filmmakers didn't know what to do with the nifty elements they created, leaving a muddled, dragging and repetitive second half.

I wish it worked better.
50 out of 59 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Lost in the cellar?
timiaan15 April 2021
Warning: Spoilers
Was really rooting for this to work, it has so many elements for a great horrorstory (all of them really). Crazy family members, a deserted island, a creepy house and an even creepier possessed toy. Even a shot of the mysterious cellar steps in 5 minutes running time (which must be a record). Unfortunately the script might have got lost in the cellar too. Or did the dog eat the final version? Pity, because styling, acting, sound design and setup promised so much. Fun, but unnecessarily confusing.
46 out of 55 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Some very tense moments
jfgibson7319 July 2021
Warning: Spoilers
So here is a movie with some very suspenseful moments. A man with memory loss is brought to a remote island to watch over a friend's niece. As it unravels, you learn that there was a murder conspiracy involving locking the niece's father in a basement until he commit suicide from the anxiety of claustrophobia. The main character was in on the plot, but the uncle pushed him off a building, which caused the memory problems. So it is weird with twists and turns, and it involves being strapped to a harness in a house where something else might be going on. By far the most memorable moments were in the basement when we see the murdered mother. There is a sequence where the main character has to crawl into the wallspace where the mother's corpse has been hidden that was very tense for me. I was fine with the ending--the uncle gets trapped in the basement with the reanimated mother while the main character walks free. There are also some sequences with a toy rabbit that taps a drum when something comes near. I thought this was just slightly above average and worth a watch.
20 out of 23 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Very slow, however there's some good stuff if you're patient enough
jtindahouse9 June 2021
This movie is going to lose a lot of people in the first 30-40 minutes unfortunately. In the modern world of cinema where audience attention spans are at an all-time low, people just aren't going to stay focused on a movie with this slow of a start. If there was an opening scene that hinted at things to come, maybe. But there really is nothing promised in that opening. Some people love the slow-burn, no doubt about it, and those people are going to have a great time with this one. But not the majority I fear.

After that slow start things do start to pick up a bit and an interesting set-up finally arises. I was ready for this. But then no sooner has this set-up presented itself, before it falls back into the recesses of nothingness for another period. This was a little frustrating and by this point in the movie I really wasn't having a good time. So how did I come to a score as high as 6/10 you're probably wondering?

The ending to this movie was very interesting. It still struggled mightily with pacing issues, however there is one scene near the end that was as well done of a horror scene as I have seen in a while. Rarely does anything potentially supernatural give me the slightest bit of interest these days, but this had me on the edge of my seat. A very impressive scene.

I also liked that the film was in no way relying on jump-scares. For my memory there isn't a single one throughout the film. All the horror is done through slow reveals, tension building and creepy imagery.

It's important to remember this is a debut effort from Damian Mc Carthy (interesting name). He'll learn a lot from the feedback he gets on this film and with the small showings of excellence that this film has he could put out something truly special one day. Watch this space.
44 out of 55 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Great visuals and concept but loses suspense and pacing with poor ending.
jakeben25 October 2020
First off I relish watching any Irish horror film being from Dublin and a big horror buff I'm always on the look out for a great Irish horror film and there have been at least a couple. I really wanted to love this film after seeing the great trailer and poster. Top marks for the trailer and poster. This film had my full and undivided attention up to the first hour passing and unfortunately it really began to lose me thereafter. I really wondered why that was. I think the story is gaining momentum for the first hour, it's really well shot, it sounds great and the story is original but when it boils down to it the characters in the film were quite difficult to really relate to and emphathize with. I didn't care what happened to the main character in the latter moments of the film and the suspense had vanished. 'Caveat' feels like a great idea for a short film that was then used for a feature film instead. It feels very long and a bit repetitive after a short period of time. I wasn't interested in any of the characters and I think that's the film's downside. There wasn't any bad acting or anything like that I just didn't feel anything for any of those characters. Maybe such a small cast also added to my feelings of disinterest. The ending in particular felt very weak, there was no pay off at the end at all. Great photography, great sound design but uninteresting characters, a muddled narrative, very light on any horror of any kind. I really wanted to love it but the last half an hour lost me completely. There is certainly real talent behind this film in particular behind the lense but it won't be a rewatch for me. 5/10
47 out of 58 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Great Directorial Debut!
CronenbergsMonster29 June 2021
Considering this is the director's first outting, this film is pretty remarkable. On just a shoe-string budget, the film manages some great cinematography, set design, performances, and a few genuine chills. Unfortunately, where the movie falters is in the writing. The plot has far too many holes, and the character's make constant, border-line incomprehensible decisions. If you can turn off your critical thinking for a majority of the film, and just appreciate it for it's atmospheric tension, you'll find there are some really promising and enjoyable moments/ideas strewn throughout.

Considering how over-run the horror genre is with terrible cash grabs, it's always exciting to see a director who is clearly talented and has their own unique voice and vision; even if the end result is a bit messy. Can't wait to see what the director does next!
19 out of 23 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Decent movie, but with a lot of plot holes
mohaniyer-6903217 December 2021
Warning: Spoilers
The movie had potential, but it is squandered due to how illogically the characters behave. In real life, people would behave completely opposite, but if the characters in the movie were to do that, the movie would end in 15 minutes. Obviously this won't do, so they make the most unrealistically illogical decisions to keep the film plodding along. These instances pile up so high, that you can't suspend your sense of disbelief any more.

Which sane individual would allow himself to be chained by a shady stranger and left alone on a spooky island?

Which sensible person would leave the crossbow within reach of his opponent after turning the tables on her and chaining her?

When he discovers that the painting is haunted, won't he call the cops instead of calling the very man who put him in the predicament in the first place?

When he puts his hand in the hole to reach the phone the second time and the girl grabs it, won't he immediately wrench his hand back, instead of waiting for her to break his finger?

Why would he leave the girl on the island in the end?

There are many such things which don't make any sense in the film. It hampers your enjoyment of the movie. The atmosphere, acting and other things are great though.
13 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Freaky drumming rabbit.
deloudelouvain29 November 2021
If I would collect movie props that drumming rabbit toy would be the first thing I would buy. I'm not sure, no in fact I'm 100% sure, that thing wouldn't be allowed in the house by my wife. It was creepy and fun to watch. The movie has a good suspense level, and some mystery that keeps you interested. I thought Jonathan French was very convincing in his role, pretty good acting of him. The horror is there but it's mild, it's all more about the suspense and mystery. Overal the story is fine but could have been better. It's good enough for a one time viewing though.
23 out of 29 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
YIKES!
pjkblue-359267 January 2022
Warning: Spoilers
Outside of the set design and atmosphere, this is quite a mess.

Let me get this straight ("jacket", LOL!). You are offered a job to be an "in-home companion" for a woman with mental health issues; on a secluded island in a house that hasn't been maintained; then you have to wear a restraint that comes with a chain, but not the "crazy" person; Really? How about..."uhhh, take me back to the mainland? This isn't what I was told at the interview." Questions: why doesn't the chain ever get caught on something? Why does it not reach the bathroom? Where is the food? Why is a dog chained-up outside? If he was clever enough to get access to use the phone, why didn't he just get the key to the restraint which was only a few inches away? Also, wouldn't you just unbuckle a lot of the straps and wiggle free of the leather vest? Who pays the bills? How does she eat, drink, toilet or otherwise exist? What was so difficult about getting into that tiny room that was only covered by 1/2" sheetrock? You needed a saw? What's the story about the creepy rabbit-drummer? Why didn't he think of picking the lock on the chain in the basement to get free? And why did I spend +/-90 minutes watching this? If you make a horror/psychological thriller, how about giving the viewer some foundational background?

Like I always say...at least the cast and crew got a payday.
27 out of 37 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Effective Atmospheric Horror Film
Reviews_of_the_Dead3 August 2021
This was a movie that I heard about thanks to some podcasters that I respect. They seemed to enjoyed this, so I was intrigued to check it out. It makes it even easier that it available on Shudder. Now I did read the synopsis before watching it, just to see if it would work as a Featured Review for my Odyssey through the Ones on Journey with a Cinephile: A Horror Movie Podcast. That synopsis is a lone drifter suffering from partial memory loss accepts a job to look after a psychologically troubled woman in an abandoned house on an isolated island.

For this movie, we start getting to meet Olga (Lelia Sykes). She walks into a room with a toy rabbit. She keeps presenting it to different parts of the room and it comes to life, playing its drum. When I mean come to life, it is a toy that I'm assuming should be wound or have batteries. It leads her down the stairs and to a small section of wall that is different. This looks to have been an opening that is fixed with drywall. She presents the rabbit and it plays its drum again. She then cuts a hole in the wall and looks in.

There is a good transition here to Moe Barret (Ben Caplan). He is speaking with Isaac (Jonathan French). He asks how long he will be staying and offers a job. It seems simple. He must watch his troubled niece. He reveals she has psychological issues, but he will pay him $200 a day. Isaac is leery about taking on this job. He does agree though.

Isaac becomes uneasy when he learns that the house is on an island. He did know that her father killed himself and her mother disappeared. Barret convinces him that it will okay so they take the boat to the house. Things get even darker when they arrive. The house is rundown. I'm surprised it has electricity. The worst part though is that Olga has issues with sleeping. Apparently, her grandmother would sleepwalk, so she created a harness that is connected to a chain in the basement. For Olga to not worry about Isaac entering her room, he has to put this on. He refuses, but Barret can be convincing.

Barret leaves and Isaac tries to find ways to pass the time. He tests to see how far he can go while wearing this harness and it isn't much. Weird things happen around him, which makes this already uneasy feeling he has worse. The chain is pulled on, but there is no one around. Lights turn off by themselves and there is haunting painting in the room he is staying. To make it even worse, when Olga she becomes too excited goes into a catatonic state and covers her eyes.

Things aren't as they seem though. This might not actually be Isaac's first time on the island. As time goes on and he starts to recover his memories, he makes some grisly discoveries within the house. Not everyone is as they seem either.

That is where I want to leave my recap. What I find interesting here is that we don't have the most complex story, but it is quite engaging. From the beginning, we are given limited information and things are revealed as we go. It seems that from the start, Barret knows who Isaac is, but since the latter has memory issues, he isn't sure how. He even makes a statement that it doesn't seem like someone he would be friends with. The memory issue gets revealed to the cause as the movie goes on and I liked that. Since Isaac is unsure of what is fully going on, we aren't sure either.

Before I get too much more into the characters themselves, I want to talk about the setting. Isaac is leery taking on this job, but it keeps getting worse as we go. The house is on an island, so it is isolated. It isn't in good shape either. That adds a creepy element to it. There is another part where a family foxes live on the island and Barret tells Isaac how their cries sound like a teenage girl screaming. To describe it like that might be on point, but how he words it makes it unnerving. The power ends up going out. It is dark and dreary even with the power on. The basement is where things also take place and that adds to the atmosphere this movie has.

With that taken care of, I'll go the acting. What I find interesting to start is our character of Barret. He enlists the aid of this guy he barely knows to look after his niece. Caplan does a solid job of being someone who is unreliable. Offering the position is only the beginning of this. The more that Isaac learns during his time on the island and as his memory comes back, the more we realize that Barret might be playing him as well as spinning half-truths.

French is also good as Isaac. He asks the right questions and we that every time he is faced with a decision, he makes the right choice. The problem is that he is pressured which causes him to change his mind. In the beginning though, the job sounds weird, but the money is good. The more he learns, the more he realizes that is a bad idea. His memory loss at first felt convenient, but as it goes on, it makes sense. He doesn't know who he can trust. As I said, I like that we don't know things until he does.

Then finally I want to go into the character of Olga. We know what Barret says about her. She is right there in the beginning, but we don't get to know her until probably 25-30 minutes into this movie. She is sitting in her catatonic state, which is creepy. She seems to be a similar situation as Isaac of not knowing who to trust, her uncle or this man who is here to 'look' after her. I thought Sykes performance was good to along with her co-stars.

With that out of the way, I think next should be the effects, cinematography and the soundtrack. I am combining this as they all contribute to the atmosphere with is the best part of the movie. Since the setting is so good, I like how it is lit. The cinematography helps to bring this location to life. There are also some creepy things done with the framing that was effective for me. They don't have a lot in the way of effects, but what we get is practical. There is another character that scary looking and made me uncomfortable. The soundtrack and design were good as well. The movie does lean a bit into the music getting louder as scares are getting close. It doesn't hurt the movie, but I also think this is better than that. All these elements combine for an effective outcome.

So then in conclusion here, what this movie does best is the atmosphere. We are combining the setting with the soundtrack and how it is shot really help to build this. Coupling this with the story that might be light, but how it is presented works. The acting fits for exactly what a movie like this needs and I liked it. What we are getting here is simple, but effective and it made me uncomfortable which is what I'm looking for. I'd say that this is a good movie. One I can't recommend to everyone, but if you like a simple, atmospheric movie, then I'd give this a go.
22 out of 30 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
I've seen a lot worse
valleyjohn20 June 2021
This is the story of Isaac , who is enlisted by a shady stranger Barrett , to look after his psychologically disturbed niece Olga in a decrepit house on a deserted rural island following her father's recent suicide. The question is - has he been there before?

Not being a horror movie fan , I have to give writer and director Damian Mc Carthy credit for what it a entertainingly creepy movie.

The setting is the star of this show . The house on an island with a chain coming from the cellar. The peeling wallpaper and secret passageways. Why anyone would would agree to stay there , especially if they had been there before , Is beyond me but that's horror films for you .

The viewer is left with lots of questions.

What is the rabbit all about ?

What was the accident?

Is Mother dead?

87 minutes is a good running time for a horror film as the cliches don't outstay their welcome.

A decent first time attempt from a debut director.
26 out of 34 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Interesting movie for its visuals and sound. Tense for an hour but after that it loses its logic and it lost me too
JvH4820 April 2021
Saw this at the Imagine filmfestival, usually in Amsterdam but now 100% online. An interesting movie as far as visuals and sound is concerned. It kept me very tense for the full first hour. After that, alas, the logic failed on me. I could not care less what the protagonists did and said, and who would live or die in the end. Apart from that, the dialog was not fully understandable (due to the Irish language??), which could have made me miss some clues. The final scene was completely lost on me.
34 out of 51 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
A Totally Terrifying Mystery and Descent into Horror
scottmannen129 October 2021
This film is a descent into madness and horror as it unravels a mystery surrounding a decades old murder. Things don't add up starting immediately from the very first scene in the film. Something scary is happening but you just can't figure out what it is. That's what you feel like through the entire movie. Something unravels in the mystery that is the main plot and it connects to another mystery.

This film is terrifying on so many levels. I won't give away any spoilers but one thing is certain and that is, is that murder is afoot.

7/10. Worth the watch, but you better not watch this one alone in the dark!
13 out of 17 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
I'll cut to the point for review readers...
enriqueayalajr8 June 2021
From the people who brought you Babadook once again they executed a great suspenseful psychological horror movie... the fact that they advertised this using that fact (brought to you by the makers of Babadook) was by all means what I used to measure this movie so I came in expecting that psychological twist ... I'm a real horror fan so in this day and age it takes alot to keep me interested and it really doesn't have to be "new" or "never before done" as long as it keeps me in suspense along with some interesting scares I'm happy... now I'll agree the ending could've been much better but altogether I liked and enjoyed it... real horror fans will also... it's no Babadook but it's deff his 2nd cousin from his moms side...
20 out of 29 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Contains excellence but ultimately fails.
perisho30 June 2021
There are some fantastic images in this film, great shots that are just perfect, fantastic sets, the acting is very good, it is all around great technical film making. Way above average I think. Very spooky. The problem is the script and the story are either not there at all or weren't translated to the screen. The premise is absurd, but you can look past it. But then the story strains suspension of disbelief to its breaking point, and even in the absurd logic of the movie nothing makes sense. Nothing is explained, motivations are nonsensical, people act completely irrationally.

The people involved with this film should work with a really great story person, they would do amazing things I'm sure.
8 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
UNSETTLING.
andrewchristianjr30 June 2021
It was quite unsettling, especially in the beginning. The drummer bunny is definitely nightmare material. I liked that there was a twist in the second half as well but it wasn't that scary after all that.
12 out of 17 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Plot doesn't quite come together
digitalrep6 February 2022
Warning: Spoilers
I think there are some implausible scenarios here (why do they live on an island surrounded by water with no boats? Why doesn't Isaac remember anything? Where is all the food? Why is the house so run down? But most importantly, who would agree to that situation?) but even if you look past those, the plot doesn't quite come together in the end.

It's a thriller that decides, at points, to become a horror, and I think it should be one or the other (it should be a horror). All the stuff about the planned murder and the double crossing and what-not just don't gel for me. If it had been about an eccentric family living on a weird isolated island and a witch it would have been ok, I think. Maybe focusing more on the mother and re-animating her. I think then it would have been alright. But as it is it just didn't make sense.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Decent, spooky movie with a haunting atmosphere
Amthermandes20 May 2022
So an outsider takes a job to babysit a women with strange mental issues, and finds himself in a strange, paranormal conspiracy.

It's got some good moments, but if slow-moving horror with an average pay-out isn't your style, you may want to skip this one and stick to Rob Zombie or Eli Roth movies. It's a good intense horror with freaky moments, very entertaining. But it doesn't have much scares, violence, or gore, so thrill seekers may be disappointed.

Does have some issues. The ending was too ambiguous, some things aren't explained or added up, and there may be one or two "missed opportunities", but a true horror fan can appreciate this one.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Creepy and unsettling
gardengnome819 November 2021
If you can overlook the implausibility of the premise and don't question the logic of the individual characters, Caveat is a successful chamber drama with a clear focus on atmosphere.

The pacing is a bit bumpy in between and the film's stance on the paranormal is not entirely clear, but I'm happy to overlook that because I found the nightmarish pull of the story very fascinating.

Especially in a scene towards the end I really got goosebumps, which (unfortunately) is really rare for me.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
pretencious and silly
yotamfreyman16 June 2021
Warning: Spoilers
This movie tries to scare the viewer by creating a situation in which the main character finds himself fighting alone against real and unreal forces on an island with no means to escape. The main problem is that absolutely every bad thing that happens to him is a direct consequence of his unrealistic and unbelievable lack of will to live. He accepts a job from a person that calls himself his friend which he doesn't remember for some reason, discovers the job is located on isolated island and he can't swim, he has to chain himself to do the job - still goes with it. He simply lets a teenage girl to break his fingers and to shot him with a crossbow with 0 attempt of fighting back. Has an access to a phone but decides not to call the police even when the situation became really messed up. And the list goes on and on and on. Even the most stupid people have an instinct of survival. None of this would ever happen in the real life not because ghost don't exist, but because people like these characters don't. None of the motivation of any of them clear or make any sense. This movie doesn't make you scared, it leaves you wondering how isolated from the reality one must be to write such a script. The ending is also very weak and random. Why the mom? What's up with the rabbit toy and what is the problem of the crossbow girl? Why does she do whatever she does? No clue.
22 out of 51 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
A fantastic Directorial debut that kept me up at night
georgia-j8 June 2021
I have been devoting the last few years to watching as many horror films as possible, Caveat stands out as one of the more original and wonderfully executed films I've seen. Twisted, grim and full of moments that make the hair on the back of your neck stand up or leave you crushing the life out of your couch cushion.

As my uncle says dryly of a good horror film 'you won't fall asleep' for me that meant during and after Caveat.
32 out of 47 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Atmospheric and suspenseful
What-a-Punk14 June 2021
It's grim and beautiful, but ends ubruptly with no real culmination.
6 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
a sleeper
msalkin-4667712 November 2021
Warning: Spoilers
A sleeper but not in the good way. A horror flick that put me to sleep a few times during the film isn't my cup of tea. There are a number of creepy devices but they don't cohere into a meaningful thread. Perhaps nothing is as it seems to be - a morbidly haunted house and both Ben Caplan's and Leila Syke's misdirection and a healthy dog tied up outside who apparently is never fed are the writer's idea of keeping us guessing.

That's not a bad idea it's difficult to guess when asleep.
4 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
An exercise in restraint that's as effective as your appreciation for it's less is more aesthetics
youngcollind19 August 2021
The plot is weaving and original, staying linear without drifting too far into the abstract, with the occasional unfortunate stretch in logic. The tone is uniformly bleak, maintaining consistent feeling of dread and unease, aided by a fully realized vision in the sound and visuals. It's low and slow pacing is admirable for missing many overblown cliches, but it does occasionally drift into tedium.
4 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
An error has occured. Please try again.

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed