"The Knick" Ten Knots (TV Episode 2015) Poster

(TV Series)

(2015)

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
Soderbergh is back, at full speed
sportello2917 October 2015
Warning: Spoilers
It's 1901 and the New York's Knickerbocker hospital is planning an expansion. Dr. Edwards is the acting chief of staff, with Dr Chickering as his patient assistant. With the usual racial tensions being on the rise, coupled with a complicated family situation, Dr. Gallinger is still on leave, yet unable to overcome his ego and come back working under Dr. Edwards.

Mr Barrow is busy handling the new hospital building, whilst simultaneously trying to settle his debt with Mr Wu, the owner of the Asian opium whore-house that Dr. Thackery used to frequent. Lucy is turn keeping busy with her nurse duties, whilst hopelessly writing letters to Thack, hoping he would get well sooner.

And finally the amazing Dr. Thackery. Soderbergh plays an almost too sarcastic, grimy, suspenseful joke on the viewer by initially showing Thack on duty, performing a nose correction surgery on a patient, in what seems to be a private setting of some sort, rather then a hospital. The wave of optimist that John has gotten better quickly vanishes with the smoke, as he sadly offers additional services for a few vials of heroin or cocaine. After all, the way season 1 ended, we should have not expected Thack to get any better.

A visit from an impatient and overwhelmed Gallinger only further emphasizes how Tchackery's situation has not gotten any better, while John begs Everett to steal some drugs for him, at the same time checking his watch every other minute, clocking the time until the next dose.

Powered by anger, disappointment and disgust Gallinger literally steals Thack from 'rehabilitation' center and takes him on a brutal boat ride through the ocean, where John has no means to escape, with an attempt to cure the disease and bring Dr. Thackery back to life and to the Knickerbocker.

Needless to say, The knick picked up right where it had left of. Soderbergh does a masterful job in lensing these times in a very dark, vintage-like manner. Different groups of characters and places have drastically different backgrounds, musical scores and color palettes, which makes The Knick truly stand out.

The plot itself is highly intriguing, indulging and interesting, however coupled with a steady, moody, unforgiving hand of Steven Soderbergh and minimal, ambient, spacey sounds of Cliff Matrinez, truly make The Knick one the most beautifully and unique show on the television.
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
The worst episode of the show I've seen in either of the seasons
yavermbizi1 January 2021
Warning: Spoilers
My overall rating of "The Knick"'s Season 2: 4/10

So how does Dr. Gallanger kidnap an unwilling Dr. Thackery from his sanatorium undetected, and bring him to the hitherto- and afterwards-unmentioned boat? And how can he trust in Thackery's sanity on the boat? And shouldn't he be with his wife, generally speaking? And why does Dr. Chickering stay at the Knick, wouldn't his falling-out with Lucy and absence of Dr. Thackery induce him to follow his father's advice and find other employment?

These are just a few of my issues with this thing (everything involving Cornelia making up a big portion of the rest - and by the way, isn't it hilarious that for most of these 2 seasons we were essentially expecting the Showalter patriarch to sexually prey on Cornelia, his daughter-in-law, but no, turns out he's just a habitual personal space invader, no sexual intent at all?), but believe me there's much more. However, there are some compelling moments and characters, and there is that initial wholesomeness of Mrs. Gallanger's reappearance and her husband's loyalty (when he's not out on boat trips, that is) that keeps it redeemable.
0 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed