Nobody, least of all Pam, knows how to handle her long-lost daughter Eve, so they ask Sheldon for his counsel. The more Eve is brought into the fold, the more it rankles Tara, who doesn't believe Eve is who she says she is.
Pam accuses loved-up Carrie of being the one who landed Leo in the hospital and reveals to the family she's suspicious of Sheldon. The Jones family devises a plan to neutralize all their enemies once and for all.