"The No. 1 Ladies' Detective Agency" Poison (TV Episode 2009) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
The laced tea
jotix10017 August 2010
Warning: Spoilers
As it is always the case, Mme. Ramotswe gets a handful of cases that she must resolve. Someone dies at 2pm every Friday at the local hospital. Dr. Sibenke, a Zimbabwean doctor, is blamed for three consecutive deaths. Being a refugee, he is singled out because the patients were all under his care. When he contact Precious Ramotswe, he finds himself under suspicion for having killed elderly people. The solution is to keep an eye on the ward. She believes whoever is killing the patients will be discovered as he, or she, tries to do the deed. The surprise comes in an unexpected way, that will clear Dr. Sibenke of all charges and his reputation will be restored.

Another case involves the father of Tabitha, a young woman that oversees the welfare of young orphans. Her father is visibly afraid about something he might be hiding in his store. Mme. Ramotswe enlists Tabitha's help to see what might be in the storage room that is such a concern for her father. What they discover is a case containing two ivory tusks that are probably going to be smuggled out of the country.

To add to her load of work, she is visited by Rre Makgothi, an executive that wants her to find out about who is trying to poison his family. Since they live in a farm, he invites Precious Ramotswe to spend a night at their place. The patriarch, who is blind, has two wives. There is bad blood between the two women. His half brother and his wife are related from the second wife. Precious suspects the poisoning comes from the chef who has come from a big hotel and prepares the food.

Precious has been advised only to eat what the others are eating. She is awaken during the night with cramps and she has to rush to the bathroom nauseous. Early in the morning she finds a cup of steaming tea left by her door, only to realize it is also poisoned when the maid comes in with her breakfast. Breaking into the safe she not only discovers who is poisoning the family, as well as being trafficking with the ivory.

Charles Sturridge directed the screenplay by Nicholas Wright, based on the beloved detective novels by Alexander McCall Smith. This episode was a pleasant chapter in the life of Precious Ramotwe, the sassy detective that has great intuition, as well as an innate sense of being in the right place at the right time in order to solve the cases brought to her.

The series owe a great deal to Jill Scott who gives life to the detective. Ms. Scott is close to one's image of Precious from the reading page. Anika Noni Rose is also a fine comedy actress who gives life to the prissy Grace Makutsi, the secretary. The African actors do a good job under Mr. Sturridge direction.
5 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Surpassingly Excellent!
doublechocolatebarbie26 February 2013
My husband and I have just watched Episode1, The Pilot. We are very impressed with the cast and the direction. We have read the first 11 books in A.M. Smith's series. So we've become acquainted with the goodness, kindness, and wisdom of the main characters. It is not too much to say that we have come to love them as dear friends.

With such a background, we are delighted to see our dear friends brought to life and to see their country of Botswana. We do not know how the film would strike someone who has not read the books. It is beautiful filming of a life & a place that are very different from our own. And yet the kindness, tenderness, & courtesy of the main characters (each in his own unique way) is universally attractive & heart-warming. Watching the films of these stories with our children, leads to discussions of these values with them. They understand & appreciate the good behaviors they see, even though the culture is very different.

We recommend that if you have not read the books, you do so. It will be well worth your time. There are delightful treasures to be found there, that are difficult to communicate in film.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Amos and Andy
tedg22 April 2009
When do exploitative stereotypes become offensive and when endearing? When they are generated outside of the target community for profit? What about when they reinforce what is seen by the target community as deeply intrinsic to the culture?

Supposing that you do not know this...

It is a cheaply produced set of artificially simple "African" fables. The chief character is a bossy, obese black woman with what is proudly called "a traditional shape." Her assistant is obsessively dedicated and daft, clearly a number two. All the men are nitwits, pompous or self-effacing. The "mysteries" are simply an excuse for our number one lady to poke around and to "explain" at the end to the collected characters, Agatha Christy-style.

This is where the manufactured wisdom comes from. Where the standard mystery would have the guilty revealed and reviled, our wise woman spends most of her time explaining why the bad events happened. Culpability is diminished and wisdom about how to repair lives is doled out.

I found it not only trite, but offensive. I imagine that few others will until a few years have passed and the idea of "ethnic identity" matures past this sort of fable.

Ted's Evaluation -- 1 of 3: You can find something better to do with this part of your life.
4 out of 25 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed