(TV Series)

(2020)

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
A New Girl Scout Type Alternative
DKosty12325 July 2020
Warning: Spoilers
WE ARE THE RADICAL MONARCHS documents an Oakland-based alternative to the Girl Scouts - specifically for girls of color, ages 8-13. The girls earn badges for units on social justice, such as Black Lives Matter, Radical Beauty, Disability Justice, and being an LGBTQ ally. They face challenges in growing the organization, both pre-and-post the 2016 election.

This group might resent my comparing them with the Girl Scouts as they are not selling cookies. They are selling activism and interestingly seem to have some differences from the current agenda. Their classes pitch History of where they come from to arrive where they are now. The history they teach might come as a shock to some folks.

The history of the Black Panthers, is just one of the controversial groups they teach the history of. When they teach it thankfully, they are trying to teach how these groups contributed to civil rights. That's good because if they taught the facts behind some of the things these groups did, there would be a lot of issues that would not make sense.

Activism is what girl scout aged students are learning here. The efforts are new and according to the show there are 4 of these troops in California. Besides the doctrines and agendas, they do friendships, tent camping, and some of the other activities that those scouts do. What they do different is teach political agendas and have merit badges for Black Lives Matter that go on sashes like the Girl Scouts use.

What might shock someone with a long memory is that teaching the young and impressionable at this age, making their politics robotic, is something that was very much done in Dictatorships in the past. The name of the group is hardly Democratic in meaning and conflicts with those who hold Democracy in their dogma. They are being taught to be radical and rule their lives with activism.

Whether or not this agenda is for everyone, is a matter of conjecture. Parts of it are being brought main stream currently. Considering this training as these kids grow up, main stream might evolve more though a lot of times this type of indoctrination winds up doing more harm than good historically.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
Political indoctrination at its finest
leslieflemons4 March 2023
Warning: Spoilers
I've never heard of this show until today. When I saw what this woman was teaching these girls, I was disgusted. She was talking to them about sex and other inappropriate things. I'm all for teaching kids about treating each other with respect, but putting a political agenda is different. Young students, no matter what grade level they're in, come to school to learn, not to be indoctrinated. Schools should be as neutral as possible. If students want to learn about sex, they can learn from their parents or wait until middle or high school. They should NOT be learning this in elementary school! They're too young. The modern education system is failing our kids right now! I'm glad i didn't learn all this trash when I was in school.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed