"Star Trek: The Animated Series" One of Our Planets Is Missing (TV Episode 1973) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
6 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Star Trek: The Animated Series - One of Our Planets is Missing
Scarecrow-8828 December 2015
Warning: Spoilers
"It is like a huge bull grazing here and there in the pasture of the universe."

This has a lot of conflict the Enterprise crew will encounter in quite a busy plot for a cartoon of Star Trek. In fact, this episode is so well written and realized, it could have been acceptable for the live action series it emulates! The plot: the Enterprise crew encounters what appears to be a red cloud that seemingly "eats planets"! In fact, the ship itself is consumed, but their shields keep them from being digested. Get this: the cloud is an actual intelligent life form and a planet lies ahead in its path for consumption that holds millions of people! So Kirk and company must determine a course of action to keep it from reaching the planet and killing all those people while consuming and digesting the planet as a nutritious food.

There are a series of decisions and events that emerge giving this episode, "One of Our Planets is Missing", a serious consideration for the best of the Star Trek cartoon. Not just that, but I think serious Star Trek fans should seek this episode out and disregard the notion that perhaps a cartoon in the 70s was intentionally written for six year olds. In actuality, I think this episode was written for all manner of ages and intellectually "One of Our…" has meat on its bones. I love that care was given to the stories during the cartoon's run, as serious dilemmas develop where Kirk and his crew must solve within a small window of time. Here in this episode he has like three hours before the cloud reaches the planet, must contend with antimatter that could explode the ship upon even slight impact, contemplate killing an intelligent life form in order to save millions more, come up with a solution to the energy drained from the Enterprise the longer they remain in the cloud, and consider Spock mind-melding with the cloud in the hopes of talking it out of eating planets containing living beings (and convincing it to return to where it came from). There's an actual mind meld where the cloud enters Spock's body, with Kirk and crew allowing it to see what dies due to its consuming of planetary bodies, with Spock and the cloud actually conversing with each other. Scotty comes up with an ingenious plan to use the antimatter and pieces of the consumed planet (that was uninhabited, which allowed the Enterprise crew to detect the cloud in the first place) as matter to help power the Enterprise.

This episode kept coming up with surprises and has so much active plot development; I was always captivated by the construction and conclusion. What an intelligently written show. How the cloud's anatomy is compared to a human's (the use of Dr McCoy is exceptional), and the grueling obstacle of the Prime Directive in terms of killing an intelligent life form further enhance this excellent animated episode which deserves to stand proud alongside its live action big brother.
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Inner Space...
Xstal28 February 2022
There's a cloud that likes to eat and digest, planetary matter it aims to divest, starship goes down the channel, of its elementary canal, before finally being expressed.

A gaseous anti-matter sentience consumes populated planets for energy before Spock makes it aware from inside the error of its ways.
7 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
" the opening on the other side "
schlagzeugplayer19 August 2019
Warning: Spoilers
Umm so make it to the backside of the " cloud", yup and where is food expelled ? Okay that aside it seems that STOP HERE SPOILER! IT seems that a mind meld w such a great being would damage Spock. 🤔
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Vintage "Old" Star Trek
Hitchcoc17 March 2017
This is the tired old plot line that was used about six times in the original series. There is a life force out there that needs energy to survive. The Enterprise encounters a cloud that is "eating" everything in its path. Unfortunately, one of the things is a planet with millions of people on it. They will all die when the planet is consumed. The ship must negotiate the inside of the thing and avoid touching the walls. It would cause an explosion and destroy the ship. Since this cloud is sentient, what can Enterprise do to make it understand their plight? Sadly, the solution is tired and far-fetched, to say the least. I imagine some of these plots were thrown together with a deadline in sight.
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Rather familiar but with a totally silly ending.
planktonrules9 April 2015
This episode of the animated "Star Trek" is very reminiscent of several other Trek episodes--particularly "The Doomsday Machine" and especially "The Immunity Syndrome". Because of its familiarity, Trekkies will probably like it since it seems much more like a real Trek show than the previous episodes. On the other hand, it's not exactly original and the ending is pretty stupid.

There's a planet-eating cloud in space. It's going to eat Mantilles and kill millions unless the Enterprise can stop it. But there is a problem--the Prime Directive doesn't want Federation craft killing other life--and the cloud is alive! So what will they do? Yup-- call on Spock to do a mild meld with this thingie and ask it to leave, of course! You just have to see this part of the show--it's unintentionally funny.

I gave this one a 5 because like all these cartoons, the animation totally sucks and the story idea not exactly original.
2 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Spock's Mindmeld Saves the Day Again
Samuel-Shovel15 November 2018
Warning: Spoilers
In "One of Our Planets is Missing", the Enterprise runs across a bizarre cloud-like creature moving across the galaxy eating up planets and turning them into energy as it goes. It is soon coming across an inhabited Federation planet that doesn't have enough time to evacuate its population. Kirk and the crew must figure out a way to stop the cloud before it's too late.

The Enterprise gets too close and is engulfed by the cloud which has some strange kind of digestive system they are passing through. Kirk considers blowing up the Enterprise and taking the cloud down with it but first Spock tries a mindmeld with the cloud. The cloud learns about our civilization; we're like ants compared to it and wasn't even aware of our existence. Spock convinces it to leave and saves the day.

Other reviews on here have succinctly covered it: this is a tired plot for this show. They've done similar ones over and over again. The only difference with this one is that it's animated (and poorly at that). The only part I enjoyed was the inclusion of a speaking role for my man Arex. Besides that, extremely skippable.
1 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed