"Pokémon" Sekiei Stadium! Vs Hiroshi! (TV Episode 1999) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
5/10
Some would think it's not just Charizard would be fired
MarkLynnIreland12948 August 2022
This is one of the worst episodes in the first series of Pokémon, or a bad episode of one of the best TV shows. The plot seems quite rushed (with flaws could've been avoided) and lacks logic to the huge extent.

When Ash is speaking with Misty and Brock and warn him about his upcoming match against Ritchie, Ash says that there would be nothing to keep him from beating Ritchie. I wouldn't bet my life on that, Ash.

Surely this is one episode where the Team Rocket trio are unlikeable and/or annoying, even they go as far as kidnapping Ash repeatedly going after Pikachu.

Not sure whether it'd be possible if the match would be postponed if Ash gives the reason why he was late. Then the battle is rushed goes for the last three minutes.

Surely, Squirtle still carry on battling as wasn't knocked out whilst dozed off sleep by Butterfree sleep powder. That's an actual error as sleep powder doesn't knock Pokémon unconscious, it's a status condition.

Indeed, after Pikachu was out, Ash couldn't use Bulbasaur against Ritchie's Charmander, yet why Ash didn't use or should've had Kingler or Muk or numerous Tauros - instead of using his powerhouse yet disobedient fire-type - certainly the worse way he possible lose in the whole series.

At first, Ash swallows up his disappointment for Ritchie's sake and accepts defeat, only in the next episode he's turns moody and downcast.

Many would think it's really because of Team Rocket's shenanigans as Ash, not only turns up late for his match, he also has an exhausted team including Pikachu and Pidgeotto.

On a positive side: without this episode, we wouldn't have classic beloved episode "Charizard Chills" in the next series. And, like the next episode (final one of series 1), it brings the message that failure isn't the end of the journey and learn from your mistakes which makes you a better person.

Anyway, not much a likeable Pokémon episode, despite nostalgia I still have.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
This episode made me hate Team Rocket
elonmusk-is_a_moron20 August 2022
Warning: Spoilers
The other reviewer has a point

It's not so much the fact Ash/Satoshi loses, the bad thing about it is the lazy and contrived way in which it happens, almost if the Universe itself wanted Ash to lose just to bring a point about how losing is not so bad.

Maybe if Ash had lost in a fair battle against Richie, the message would have been better delivered. But instead, he loses because the usual Team Rocket shenanigans: In fact, it was because this episode I started to strongly dislike them, and rather than being some adorable loser villains, they started to become an annoying pest, like a forced joke that has outstayed their welcome. And they become even more annoying in the Johto series. Honestly, I don't see why some fans love them so much (To the point of not wanting them to be removed from the series)

Sorry, but in my opinion the Pokemon manga by Toshiro Ono did the right thing giving them a nice sendoff (James and Jesse stop being villains and get married, living happily ever after) Way better than we got in the anime.

So yeah, losing is not so bad, but gesh, this whole episode feels like one big, stupid diabolus ex machina. Worse, it inspired a horrid tradition of Ash having to lose every league in forced, contrived ways that end being just plain infuriating.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed