"Studio One" They Came to Baghdad (TV Episode 1952) Poster

(TV Series)

(1952)

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
5/10
unremarkable TV version of Agatha Christie Story
scott-palmer28 September 2009
Warning: Spoilers
They Came to Baghdad was made for TV in the U.S. as part of the Studio One anthology series. It was shown on May 12, 1952, and was based on the novel Christie wrote the previous year.

Story opens with a rather unconvincing murder attempt that goes awry, followed by a newspaper headline with a warning from Winston Churchill. Anna Scheele, Richard Baker, and Inspector Dakin are working for the "good guys," the free nations of the world. The plans of a new secret weapon has been obtained by a man called Carmichael who is supposed to meet the trio in Baghdad.

Enemy agents discover a girl, one Victoria Jones, who bears such a resemblance to Miss Scheele that they dupe her (Jones that is) into accompanying them to Baghdad. Edward Goring, the chief bad guy, has gained the trust of Miss Jones, and when she arrives at the Baghdad hotel she discovers a hotbed of spies and intrigue. Carmichael shows up, is fatally shot by the bad guys, but not before he leaves a cryptic clue with Miss Jones-thinking she is Anna Scheele. When Baker, Dakin, Jones and Scheele all get together at the end, they discover the clue is actually a coded message in the stitching of Carmichael's scarf.

This convoluted and confusing adaptation does little justice to a somewhat brilliant novel by the Queen of Crime. Performances in general are average, and June Dayton is often irritating and at times unbelievable. Only Bramwell Fletcher as Inspector Dakin gives a decent performance. An interesting curio this, perhaps in part due to the fact that it's the only attempt to ever put this novel on either large or small screen (maybe someone will do it again sometime, especially since nearly 60 years have passed).
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Worth watching only as a curiosity for Christie fans
istara20 May 2023
To say that this is not a faithful adaptation of They Came to Baghdad would be the understatement of the century.

It has most of the characters and some of the plot. The problem is the framing of it all. You can see how the producers would struggle to fit a novel like They Came to Baghdad into under an hour.

The problem is that all the charm and fun of They Came to Baghdad is lost. There's no mystery regarding who is the hero, who is the villain - a key aspect of the book. Victoria Jones' character is very much changed. The exotic settings aren't there.

It does get better - the first scene with Anna Scheele buying tartan cloth is confusing and awful. Once we're in Baghdad things are more familiar.

I don't know if anyone will ever bring a faithful adaptation of They Came to Baghdad to the screen. It might be too difficult to adapt script-wise, it might not be commercially viable. But it's something that would be fascinating to see. Maybe GenAI will make it a possibility one day.

For now, we have this. And thankfully, we still have the wonderful book it's loosely based on.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed