"Starsky and Hutch" Strange Justice (TV Episode 1978) Poster

(TV Series)

(1978)

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Best laid plans
monomerd13 September 2016
Warning: Spoilers
I guess this is one of the better episodes of Season 4 but I can't say I really like it. It does give us a story line that is in keeping with typical Starsky and Hutch drama, but it is definitely darker and more negative than past episodes and reflects the changes that occurred in Season 4. Starsky and Hutch will not come out of this story with a warm, fuzzy feeling, and neither will we.

The story centers around the rape of a cop's daughter. The cop generally has followed the rules and done his job all these years and is respected, but now that the victim is his own daughter, he wants revenge because he can't count on justice. The cop shoots the rapist in a fit of rage, but does not kill him. Starsky and Hutch are assigned the rape case and are supposed to somewhat keep an eye on the cop so he doesn't do anything else stupid. In the end, they pretty much fail.

There is really no case here for Starsky and Hutch to be assigned to. The rape case is in the hands of the prosecutor. Most of what Starsky and Hutch have to do is again convince the attorney to prosecute the rapist and not just let him off easy, which is our standard 70s story line regarding crime and justice. Since we've all seen this again and again in our cop shows, it is no surprise that the cop wants to take matters into his own hands to get justice for his daughter. The cop hatches an elaborate plan to get the rapist killed by other cops in the course of a crime orchestrated by the cop himself. It works, almost. Starsky and Hutch dissect the plan and try to derail it, but they are too late.

The story is handled very seriously and darkly. Mary Crosby plays the shattered rape victim almost too well. She can barely respond to anyone and her father is completely at a loss to comfort or help her. I was glad that they didn't try to have a scene of Starsky and Hutch questioning her. Starsky and Hutch do question the roommate, and that is where we mostly get our lesson on how society is responsible for the objectification of women. We wouldn't want to have missed that. (I have a copy of the script for this show, and there was even more information about rape that we were originally supposed to be hit with in some of the dialog. A large percentage never made it off the pages.)

The fact that Starsky and Hutch can't stop the father from taking his revenge and end up having to arrest him leaves a bad taste for everyone at the end of this episode. Hutch is especially despondent and disgruntled. DS was playing a very unhappy Hutch in most of Season 4, and this story gave him a lot to work with. (I miss the Hutch that was more optimistic about life every time I watch anything in Season 4). I gave this show a 7 rating because it was well-done, but I don't feel like it is one I will want to watch again.
7 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
'You'll Meet Him...One Way Or The Other!'
JasonDanielBaker28 February 2015
Leslie (Mary Crosby), daughter of a veteran Los Angeles police detective, is raped in her sorority house by a deranged scuzzo (Joseph Reale). Her over-worked cop father Lieutenant Dan Slate (Kenneth McMillan), normally a steadfast professional goes ballistic and tries to kill the apprehended assailant who is only too delighted to gloat about what he has done.

Detectives Ken Hutchinson (David Soul) and David Starsky (Paul Michael Glaser), friends and colleagues of Slate's plead with their superior Police Captain Dobey (Bernie Hamilton) to be given the case to try to exonerate Slate. The widowed vet, whose daughter has become nearly catatonic from the attack, muses that he has nothing left. His plans don't include vindication.

'Young woman in peril' story lines were a staple of titillating old detective magazines and found their way into movies in the 1970s. Brutal violence committed by intruders in sorority houses was a newer phenomenon which appeared mainly to exist in slasher movies. The chief threat in sorority houses was, and is, hazing by older sisters.

The theme of vigilantism and critique of a criminal justice system that appeared to favor criminals was very much in vogue at the time. Casting Kenneth McMillan - an actor who so often portrayed villains, as a vengeful dad made for an intriguing turn even amidst less plausible aspects of the plot. It offers subtext on a form of villainy.

I always found Mary Crosby convincing and wondered why she never became a bigger star. Other guest-stars Kenneth McMillan and Carl Anderson were as serious and competent at acting as the series regulars. The level of hard work and talent could still be lost within the confines of a production designed to meet the demands of a superficial formula.

Solid performances all around don't necessarily square everything. But I appreciate the effort here and in other entries in this series - one seemingly nobody else looked at as anything other than crass, insubstantial schlock churned out as an afterthought by producers and the ABC network.
6 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
bello
petjack-4810429 August 2021
A noteworthy thing about season 4 is that each episode has a different music. Also it is certainly very underestimated because this reason I give everyone good marks, however this is also a really great episode.
2 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
S&h
thirumavijayane10 August 2021
Its starsky and hutch do i need to explain abkut may valutation?

And it deals with dark themes wich you can t se in the first seasons.
2 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Getting justice is frowned upon
LaverneandShirleysucks11 December 2021
A cop goes after the scum who raped his daughter and when he succeeds in ridding him from the world, he's treated as the bad guy in the end. The only good thing about it is that the cop still says it was worth it as he's being arrested while Starsky & Hutch look at him all disgusted. The man's daughter was raped by the monster and had every right to take him out as far as i'm concerned.

I wonder if they'd feel differently if either men had daughters themselves?
13 out of 35 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed