(TV Series)

(1963)

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
Claudine Longet's Debut in "One of a Continuing Series"
Aldanoli11 August 2007
This episode marked the first of two appearances that Claudine Longet put in on this series (also marking her acting debut) as "Yvette Gerard," a lovely young Frenchwoman (only 20 at the time) who, for some reason, has the hots for Lt. Parker! (Longet would reprise the role in "One Enchanted Weekend" later in this season, and would also appear in essentially the same role in the movie version of McHale's Navy in 1964, although there her character was "Andrea Bouchard.") This was one of the first of the continuing story lines that the show followed; Christy and Gloria were married in the show in episode no. 6 ("Operation Wedding Party") and although not seen, she's referred to here as expecting their first baby. The storyline would be extended in the late Season 2 episode "A Da-Da for Christy," which would also pick up on this episode's convention of the child being named for all the members of the crew (even though Gavin McLeod was gone by the time of that episode), and would feature the other appearance of Cindy Robbins as Gloria.

These continuing story lines (both of Christy's family and of Yvette's presence -- not to mention the third appearance of Adm. Reynolds, this time with a first name, "Roscoe") helped gave the series a sense that these were real people and not just characters who otherwise existed in a kind of "eternal present," where every episode's events were completely disassociated from every other episode in the series. This was also at least the second episode where Ernest Borgnine's participation was limited to a few minutes at the beginning and end of the episode (see, e.g., episode no. 13, "The Captain's Mission"), suggesting that Borgnine may have had some commitment elsewhere that the writers and producers accommodated by writing a "McHale-less" episode that could be "framed" with a prologue and epilogue written around a flashback -- as here. This did give Ensign Parker more screen time, and it was nice to see the young lady show an interest in her "cap-i-tain" even though her attraction to Parker seems a little unlikely. Tim Conway and Claudine Longet had a pleasant chemistry, and their scenes together are amusing.
8 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
One of the better episodes from the first season.
kfo949421 October 2014
This episode begins with McHale being on leave in New Caledonia and Ensign Parker has the command of the PT boat. They have just rescued two French nationals off an island that the Japs had occupied and on their way back to the base. The two people are Mr Gerard and his beautiful young daughter Yvette Gerard.

Later Christy gets a letter from his wife Gloria, that was married earlier in the season, saying they will be expecting a baby. Gloria, who is not seen during the show, is going to name the baby after everyone in McHale's crew because they helped in getting the couple married before she shipped out. The crew thinks of a plan where they can raise money for the new baby. They are going to have a raffle and the winner is going to get a nice dinner and a date with the beautiful French lady, Yvette Gerard. But they have to do one thing, keep the raffle away from Binghamton.

An enjoyable episode that featured the eye-candy of Claudine Longet playing the young Yvette Gerard. Her looks and performance is the cause of this episode taking on an entertaining aspect since the plot would have been dull without her. It is also nice to see that the writer went back to an earlier episode and recruited some of the material into a future show. Another nice part of the show is the acting of Tim Conway. He has been given buffoon type roles so far in the season but this episode brings out a more mature and likable Ensign Parker. An entertaining show.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
The Winning Number Is 867
hogwrassler14 July 2021
This episode is told mostly in flashback with Ernest Borgnine only making a token appearance. Apparently, he was obligated for another TV show and wasn't available to lead his band of merry pirates in this one. The flashback opens with Parker and the PT 73 crew rescuing two French civilians from a Japanese held island. Parker does well as a combat leader. The two civilians are a planter and his lovely daughter, Andrea Bouchard, played by Claudine Longet. Back at the base, the crew has to come up with a plan to help Christy pay expenses for his new baby, soon to be born back in the states. They come up with the idea for a raffle, selling tickets with the prize winner getting a date with lovely Andrea. She is willing to do it as she seems willing to do anything for Ensign Parker. The problem is keeping Binghamton from finding out about it. Things get complicated when Binghamton wants to take Andrea to dinner on the same night as the raffle date. But Binghamton comes across as a bit of a lady's man when Andrea puts him off for their date, and he immediately comes on to a pretty nurse Lieutenant, played by Sally Mansfield. She is charmed by his attention and agrees to have dinner with him. Old Leadbottom is even able to smoothly light her cigarette without a hitch. Eventually, the drawing is held and the winning number is 867. Then Binghamton appears and it sure looks bad. But who holds that winning number 867?
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed