"Farscape" Natural Election (TV Episode 2002) Poster

(TV Series)

(2002)

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Finding a captain for Moya
Tweekums12 September 2012
Warning: Spoilers
After Pilot's announcement that Moya can't constantly take orders from the entire crew at the same time they are taking turns to act as captain. During Crichton's stint in the role he searches for a wormhole he has predicted; at first it looks as if his calculations were inaccurate and he hands command on to Rygel; then a minute or two later a wormhole appears! They don't get time to celebrate though as suddenly everything goes black; Moya has become tangled in a space-dwelling plant. The plant starts to eat away at the metal in Moya's hull. The crew struggle to remove the plant but some of their moves make matters worse! While this is going on Aeryn tells Chiana about her pregnancy; she also tells him something that she didn't tell John... she doesn't know who the father is.

It seems that the writers have returned to having stand alone episodes rather than having an overriding story arc that dominates the season. While it is a decent story I miss the longer stories. This week threat does feel like something that might have been encountered in the early incarnations of 'Star Trek'; although it does have more humour. I found the character interaction more interesting that the plant; in many ways that just served to get them into positions where they could talk. When Aeryn told Chiana her secret it was inevitable that it would ultimately get back to Crichton; knowing the characters it was believable though. Gigi Edgely does a particularly fine job as Chiana as her character not only passes on the gossip but also trying to cover herself by saying Rygel had told her. The vote to decide the new permanent captain was well handled; I was expecting series protagonist Crichton to get the job but in a pleasant twist it went to somebody else without that choice seeming to be controversial.
11 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
the episode that most makes you lose complete faith in the crew
spasticfreakshow9 September 2011
Warning: Spoilers
There were other aha moments where the moral value of the characters of the central cast was in serious doubt, when Zahn and D'Argo cut off Pilot's arm or when Rygel went to sell them out to the PKs...but in this episode, I came to actually dislike the remaining cast. I never liked Noranti or Sikozu whatsoever (why do they trust Sikozu? it's seriously unclear why she's not in the cell next to Scorpi - this is almost a plot hole) and Rygel is only mildly likable in the best of times. I loved Zahn and liked both Stark and Crais and they're all gone, so the only characters left to feel any love for (besides the harmless Pilot and Moya) are Crichton, Aeryn, Chiana and D'Argo. In this episode, Aeryn is so completely unlikable that I don't want to keep watching. Her poor judgment in confiding in others, rather than in Crichton directly, makes her untrustworthy, but also seems out of character. I would be disappointed if he kissed her this episode - the writers have pulled a 180 with the John/Aeryn story arc - epic fail..UNLESS one disgruntled writer's goal was to get the series canceled!? I don't blame Chiana and D'Argo as much for gossiping, but their reactions are also untrustworthy. Worse, for Aeryn to not know who the father is is truly unpardonable - and the 7 cycle gestation thing is not credible at all. Why keep watching after this? D'Argo says "I really like shooting things" and then is elected captain? And not even one person votes for Crichton? Dumb and Dumber. Truly, the characters come off as immoral and stupid. It is the worst episode of the series so far - if you want to keep watching, skip this one.
7 out of 18 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed