The critics seem to completely miss the point regarding James Mason's portrayal of Rafe who although is strict and disciplined, is not a tyrant but is actually shown to have a soft centre. He was cultured and appreciated quality. He clearly enjoys playing the piano while encouraging the family members to sing along. Therefore, I think he played it beautifully and understated and it was not in any way stereotypical. The supporting cast all play their parts well and it's a good portrayal of family life in the 60's in Northern England. All things considered I think Mason deserved an oscar for his performance and it is a great shame he did not.