THIS ...... is the best they can do .... Oh My God...!!
Everything in this is poor .... casting...acting.... music ..... And its poor on its own ....Then when you put it against the 1945 version with Dorothy McGuire, Robert Young and Herbert Marshall ....Music by Roy Webb ....You realize just how pitiful it is....!!!
NONE of the romance that exudes the 1945 version is translated in this film....No matter how sentimental or sappy you may think the 45 version is .... It does what it was meant to do ... It ss a fantasy drama ... and when you go outside of this idea you lose the sweeping emotion that the story intends to deliver...
If a studio is going to commit to a remake of this film ...... They better make a much more substantial commitment than THIS...!!!
Better yet ... DON'T remake this movie .... it probably belongs in a different time anyway.
Everything in this is poor .... casting...acting.... music ..... And its poor on its own ....Then when you put it against the 1945 version with Dorothy McGuire, Robert Young and Herbert Marshall ....Music by Roy Webb ....You realize just how pitiful it is....!!!
NONE of the romance that exudes the 1945 version is translated in this film....No matter how sentimental or sappy you may think the 45 version is .... It does what it was meant to do ... It ss a fantasy drama ... and when you go outside of this idea you lose the sweeping emotion that the story intends to deliver...
If a studio is going to commit to a remake of this film ...... They better make a much more substantial commitment than THIS...!!!
Better yet ... DON'T remake this movie .... it probably belongs in a different time anyway.