I really enjoy the show but there are too many problematic elements to give it a really high rating.
There are generally five or six key features of a great film/TV narrative: 1) a fresh and interesting overall narrative arc or storyline; 2) quality sub-narratives; 3) exceptionally written dialogue; 4) interesting character development; 5) quality acting; 6) realistic visuals.
The expanse checks the box quite well on 1. It is decent with respect to 4. 5 is a mixed bag. So, also, 2. 3 is up and down as well. 6 is pretty decent.
The premise and storyline are fascinating. But, the fundamental problem with this show is that there are too many situations in which characters simply do not make obvious choices to solve a problem or communicate simple facts that would otherwise alleviate trouble. The central character played by Steven Strait is too weak and emotional. There are so many dumb decisions (especially with Thomas Jane's character, and particularly in season 2).
The female leads are well acted and are also quite compelling. The male leads not so much. Some of the sub characters are decent.
At times the dialogue is solid. At other times it just falls short.
Currently, it's a 6.5 of 10. At best a 7. At worst a 6. As to the ultimate rating of the program, a great deal of that will depend on the development of the narrative and the final outcome.
There are generally five or six key features of a great film/TV narrative: 1) a fresh and interesting overall narrative arc or storyline; 2) quality sub-narratives; 3) exceptionally written dialogue; 4) interesting character development; 5) quality acting; 6) realistic visuals.
The expanse checks the box quite well on 1. It is decent with respect to 4. 5 is a mixed bag. So, also, 2. 3 is up and down as well. 6 is pretty decent.
The premise and storyline are fascinating. But, the fundamental problem with this show is that there are too many situations in which characters simply do not make obvious choices to solve a problem or communicate simple facts that would otherwise alleviate trouble. The central character played by Steven Strait is too weak and emotional. There are so many dumb decisions (especially with Thomas Jane's character, and particularly in season 2).
The female leads are well acted and are also quite compelling. The male leads not so much. Some of the sub characters are decent.
At times the dialogue is solid. At other times it just falls short.
Currently, it's a 6.5 of 10. At best a 7. At worst a 6. As to the ultimate rating of the program, a great deal of that will depend on the development of the narrative and the final outcome.