Held in a Scottish POW camp, a group of German soldiers plot an escape while the Scots bring in an unorthodox Irish officer to work out what the Germans are plotting in this unconventional World War II movie. This is an unusual movie on a number of fronts. First off, the Germans are given more screen time and juicier characters than the Allies. Secondly, the Germans actually converse in German (with subtitles) rather than awkwardly speaking English (more common in war movies back then). Thirdly, the film attempts to show both sides of the incident, taking on the perspectives of both the German and Allied soldiers. For all its daringness to be different though, the film is not necessarily a success. It is hard to become emotionally involved in the story and find someone to root for due to the decision to show both sides in near equal depth. Also, try as Brian Keith does to make his Irishman interesting, Helmet Griem outclasses him every step of the way as the charismatic German Kapitän, which in turns makes the Germans' side of the tale more fascinating to view. Whatever the case, the film is very ably directed by Lamont Johnson, who would later go on to direct the classy likes of 'A Gunfight' and 'The Groundstar Conspiracy' and a solid supporting cast helps. Still, it is sometimes hard not to see 'The McKenzie Break' as more of a curio than anything else.
Review of The McKenzie Break
