It's 1954 Algeria. Revolution is in the air. Daru (Viggo Mortensen) is a war veteran teaching little kids in a small remote school house. Another white teacher has been killed and he's warned to leave. He refuses since his family were longtime residents. One day, prisoner Mohamed (Reda Kateb) is brought to the school. Daru is told to bring him to town for trial. Mohamed had killed his cousin. He needs to end the blood feud by getting executed by the French. Their journey is disrupted by the two warring sides.
There is beauty in the stark landscape. I like the setup until Mohamed refuses to escape after the attack. He's not much of a prisoner and that drains some of the tension. The level of duty for Daru is pretty low which also drains the tension away. Daru is projecting impossible goodness. There just isn't anything to prevent Daru from walking away. Mohamed don't seem to care about his life. There is no fight for life since both seem perfectly happy to die. I get that it's trying to say something about war and the human nature. That has some value but not much tension.
There is beauty in the stark landscape. I like the setup until Mohamed refuses to escape after the attack. He's not much of a prisoner and that drains some of the tension. The level of duty for Daru is pretty low which also drains the tension away. Daru is projecting impossible goodness. There just isn't anything to prevent Daru from walking away. Mohamed don't seem to care about his life. There is no fight for life since both seem perfectly happy to die. I get that it's trying to say something about war and the human nature. That has some value but not much tension.