10/10
Herzog, the keeper of promises
7 April 2013
Werner Herzog is a great example of someone to be trusted. Really trusted. Not only he encourages aspiring filmmakers to make their movies in any possible ways, inciting them to engage in passionate act as if it were a revolution to be made ("Steal a camera, steal raw stock! Break into a lab and do it!") but also he's a man who keeps his promises. Once he makes them (usually crazy ones), he's definitely gonna fulfill it. At one time he jumped on a cactus while filming "Even Dwarfs Started Small" just to entertain the dwarfs who survived the filming of his movie after many troubled incidents. He said he would jump on it if they managed to make the whole film and he did, carrying some scars from such act. And years later he would eat a shoe after making another absurd bet, this one more challenging to more people and more poetic in a way. He lost again and it was time to show and tell. Here's the living proof filmed by Les Blank in 1980.

The proposition was: Herzog convinced film student Errol Morris to make his first film, and if he succeed in doing so he would eat his shoes. Literally. Morris went on to make "Gates of Heaven", a documentary about a pet cemetery and its owners, which was acclaimed by critics and public starting a promising career of a future Oscar winner and a great documentarist. When the movie premiered in NY Herzog traveled all the way to pay his debts, set up a whole meal to go with his shoes - one to be eaten in front of an audience, the other one only if Morris film get a distributor.

A brave yet foolish gesture, very noble of Werner and whose purpose was exactly what he intended to do: to push Morris forward and go after his dreams. He truly believes in this human's search and conquest for their dreams, speaking of this with plenty of passion in "Burden of Dreams", also directed by Blank, where we follow Herzog's troupe while making the epic "Fitzcarraldo" and his almost impossible task of making a steam-ship crossing over a mountain among other difficulties. "Without dreams we would be like cows in the field" he says there. Combining both documentaries you have a full image of the director, a truly inspiring one, and if like he says that films can't cause revolutions but can cause some personal change, then his thoughts and acts in both films can cause a real revolution inside each viewer.

"Werner Herzog Eats His Shoe" isn't just the title, it's also about the man exposing his views on culture, television, holy war against Bonanza and commercials, and the lack of an adequate language in the media. Everything he said was truth back then and it's truer even now, more than 30 years later. Very insightful opinions. But of course, seeing the director of "Aguirre" eating the same shoes he used when he made the bet is priceless, adding garlic and tempers to make it tasteful, the audience watching him cook, laughing all the time, it's a humorous view intercut with Chaplin eating his shoes in "The Gold's Rush". I think the one thing that was missed in here was an interview with Errol Morris, he's nowhere to be found in the film, and his comments on Werner would be interesting here.

There's only one person who I can believe we'll keep his promises and that's Herzog. Many people can say many times that things will get better (when life doesn't go our way) but if Werner says that it will, then I have to believe. Why? Because he promised. And this film is just an example of someone who respect his promises, even the weirder ones. 10/10
5 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed