'Below' (terrible title) is actually three genres, an ultra-realistic WWII submarine adventure, a tense psychological mystery thriller, and a horrific ghost story. That the horrific ghost story portion is no where near as effective as the other two doesn't degrade writer-director David Twohy's achievement. It might, however, partly explain the movie's abysmal box office (less than $500,000; the sets probably cost more than that) . Twohy struggles a bit trying to integrate the genre elements. He needed have bothered. Jettisoning the ghost story entirely wouldn't have hurt the film. The three most horrific scenes don't involve the supernatural at all. One involves the sub sitting on the shallow bottom and being torn to pieces by huge hooks attached to a destroyer's anchor chain (Never seen that before; it's frighteningly plausible). The second involves divers being surprised by a school of big manta rays. The third is searching for survivors in darkened compartments incinerated by a blast of escaping hydrogen from the ship's depleted batteries.
'Below' lovingly recreates the look and feel of the 1940s in color, sound, texture and costumes and is the best period recreation since 'LA Confidential'. For example, one character collects real toy prizes from CRACKER JACK boxes. How many people in an audience would remember those?
'Below' is cast with a crew of very competent unknowns, such as Bruce Greenwood ('The Core') and Matt Davis. Olivia Williams (Bruce Willis' wife in 'The Six Sense') is probably the most familiar face. However, even she looks considerably different here. The use of unknowns works well for a submarine movie, slightly less so for a mystery. However, it doesn't work well at all for a ghost story, especially considering the large cast, since some two similar faces become confusing. Further Twohy should have studied James Wong's terrific directing of 'Final Destination'. Wong correctly let unseen forces create create his horror rather than shock ghost effects. Twohy does get it right, however, in a scene when one officer studies his own movements in a mirror and finds his reflection is not the same. This scene creates a whole new spin on the classic Marx Brothers scene in 'Duck Soup'. It's the scariest supernatural bit in the whole movie.
Below may only be a winner in two out of three of it's genres, but two out of three ain't bad. It's a keeper. I give 'Below' a '7'.
'Below' lovingly recreates the look and feel of the 1940s in color, sound, texture and costumes and is the best period recreation since 'LA Confidential'. For example, one character collects real toy prizes from CRACKER JACK boxes. How many people in an audience would remember those?
'Below' is cast with a crew of very competent unknowns, such as Bruce Greenwood ('The Core') and Matt Davis. Olivia Williams (Bruce Willis' wife in 'The Six Sense') is probably the most familiar face. However, even she looks considerably different here. The use of unknowns works well for a submarine movie, slightly less so for a mystery. However, it doesn't work well at all for a ghost story, especially considering the large cast, since some two similar faces become confusing. Further Twohy should have studied James Wong's terrific directing of 'Final Destination'. Wong correctly let unseen forces create create his horror rather than shock ghost effects. Twohy does get it right, however, in a scene when one officer studies his own movements in a mirror and finds his reflection is not the same. This scene creates a whole new spin on the classic Marx Brothers scene in 'Duck Soup'. It's the scariest supernatural bit in the whole movie.
Below may only be a winner in two out of three of it's genres, but two out of three ain't bad. It's a keeper. I give 'Below' a '7'.