Review of Hidalgo

Hidalgo (2004)
5/10
Cut to the chase.
29 April 2004
Mortensen, Sharif and others might have got away with this in a lightning raid, but oh, the teeny-soapsuds! Oh, the quicksands of sugar! Oh, the plonking exposition and the wallowing in goodbyes! Oh, the electronic leopards!

I agree that there was a good film in here, about half to two-thirds as long. Just cut four-fifths of the dialogue and there it would be.

I can see why they wanted to make this, and I can see why they wanted to make it with this cast. And there are quite a lot of good scenes, especially those in which nobody speaks. It was a worthy ambition. But it's a bloody awful script.

Please do not shoot the scriptwriter. He is doing his best.
11 out of 22 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed