Reviews

2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
Citizen Kane (1941)
10/10
An in-depth look at Citizen Kane
1 July 2006
Based on the newspaper mogul William Randolph Hearst, Citizen Kane takes us along a news reporter's quest to discover the mysterious meaning of "Rosebud," Charles Foster Kane's last words, by piecing together important chapters of his life in a series of interviews with the people who "knew" the man best. It may not be considered the most universally entertaining film, however Orson Welles's Citizen Kane is among the most interesting and revolutionary works of art of the film genre.

Orson Welles learned the taste of success very early in his career as an actor, writer, and director. Some of his first major successes include modern renditions of Shakespeare's Macbeth and Julius Caesar with the Mercury Theatre. Soon after such box office hits along with the famous War of the Worlds radio broadcast that gained him national notoriety, Welles landed a deal with Hollywood. They were so confident in him that he was offered Carte Blanche to do what ever he wanted with no limitations. Welles seized this opportunity not to make a move for his career but to make a move for the art of film. The end result was Citizen Kane.

One of the central themes of the film is the difficulty of interpreting a life. After viewing a film biography containing bulleted achievements of Charles Foster Kane's life, its producer asks his reporters, "Who, really, was Charles Foster Kane?" implying that a man is more than the sum of his achievements, material wealth or even actions. Thus reporter Jerry Thompson, played by actor William Alland, takes on the mission to find meaning in Kane's last words. However, his daunting task leads to another obstacle and central theme to the film: the unreliability of memory. In interviewing those who had been closest to Kane, Thompson finds that he can dig no deeper than biased/blurred perceptions of Kane's actions: one storyteller, Susan Alexander Kane, played by Dorothy Comingore recounts her life with Kane, her late husband, in an alcoholic rant. Another, Jetidiah Leland, a former friend of Kane played by Joseph Cotten, doesn't complete the puzzle either in his senile recollection of his relationship with Kane. Because of this, the image of Kane's life can never quite come into focus and Thompson ultimately fails in his mission.

One of the most notorious devices of Citizen Kane is the innovative cinematographic technique. The use of new camera angles, deep focus, and strategic contrast has a subtle but profound effect on the mood, thematic direction, and overall story. The combination of camera angles in the floor and ceiling along with deep focus allowed Welles to morph size and perspective making the audience very aware or unaware of the characters' size in relationship to others and their surroundings. The fact that they had to build ceilings into sets also added an element of realism. The contrast of light and dark is used to give further emphasis of importance or meaning on specific elements of a scene. One example is the blinding white snow against the dark, sullen young Kane right before he is taken away from his home. Another is the frequent radiance of Kane emphasizing his grandeur next to the inferior reporters who are cast into shadows.

Welles had been at first reluctant to enter the film-making business because of the little respect it received from the art community. But after Citizen Kane, he had single-handedly transformed the industry and revealed the true artistic potential of film. This coupled with its multidimensional layers of innovations in technology, acting, and story structure constitutes Citizen Kane's place at the top of almost all movie critics' list of film masterpieces.
1 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
An in-depth look at The White Countess
1 July 2006
The White Countess achieves the "perfect balance of romance and tragedy." It is the story of two broken souls who each end up being the remedy to the other's fall from grace. While this description may not point to anything extraordinary on its own, Natasha Richardson (Countess Sophia Belinsky) and Ralph Fiennes (Todd Jackson) dazzle us with outstanding performances in this final Merchant-Ivory film. Superb acting, complex characters, and visually stunning sets make for a realistic, timeless five-star drama.

Ralph Fiennes plays the role of Todd Jackson, a disillusioned American ex-diplomat. The loss of his family and vision to Chinese-Japanese political turmoil destroy his hopes and prospects for the world. The disappointment in the stagnant progress of the League of Nations drives Jackson away from the desperate political scene, and he attempts to shut out all reminders of an uncontrollable painful world. He goes on spending his time frequenting Shanghai's classiest bars, surrounding himself in luxury and warmth. He finds friendship in a Japanese man named Matsuda who shares his dreams to create the perfect bar. People warn Jackson that Matsuda is a feared political revolutionary; however, this has no impact on their relationship—Jackson has completely shut the doors to the outside world. Fiennes expertly sticks to his character delivering the heavy, demanding lines with eloquence while appearing to be truly blind.

In his quest to create this perfect bar he runs into Countess Sophia Belinsky a Russian Aristocrat who has fled to Shanghai escape the Bolshevik Revolution. She is living with her late husband's family and her daughter, Katya. She single-handedly supports them by prostituting herself despite their assailment and complete lack of gratitude. Jackson finds in her the perfect balance of romance and tragedy and asks her to be the centerpiece of his bar and names it of her. Natasha Richardson emanates a deep sadness and longing for a once beautiful world and lets the audience feel what Jackson finds in Countess Sophia.

The two of them succeed in creating their own controllable world. With the right music, the right crowd, and a sense of political tension, Jackson feels he has made his dream come true. However, at the end of the night, Countess Sophia must return to the slums and the outside world with all its troubles and other unpredictable variables. As Jackson's relationship with Sophia develops, he begins to realize the impracticality of his "heavy doors". This accompanied with Matsuda's luring of a "broader canvas" slowly cause Jackson to emerge from his shell. At the end of the film, Jackson and Sophia return to the outside world together with a new hope found in one another.

The themes of isolation and alienation are rampant in this film and occur on many levels. Sophia is shut off from her family and eventually abandoned because of her disgraceful job. Jackson is blind physically and mentally from the real world. They are strangers in a foreign country, a country whose sole foreign policy for the past several centuries has been isolationism (they built a wall to keep people out). These instances are not simply strewn about but are intricately woven into the plot to create a deeper, more meaningful story.

The White Countess explores devastation and new hope, heartbreak and new love, and shows us the hopelessness of walls and cages. We can always close our eyes but that doesn't mean everything around us will disappear.
35 out of 36 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed