I don't usually review movies this old, but although i've seen this before, i just had to review it and here's why.
The story is fantastically acted and intense and a lot of the time intentionally uncomfortable to watch, but i have just one gripe that spoilt a lot of my enjoyment; It's the conflation of morals that if in the real world, would make me so angry and as the actors did so well in this, the anger transcended into the movie. Let me explain more... Most of the movie is dedicated to Hugh Jackman and Jake Gyllenhaal's characters, who we are meant to see as the good guys, yet in the first 20 mins Gyllenhaal's character jumps the conclusion someone is a criminal just because they were nearby and acting weird and then threatens said suspect. Isn't innocent until proven guilty a thing in the U. S, then there's Jackman's character, who is a kidnapper, holding someone who he thinks is a kidnapper, yeah really a good guy and what happens of he's Daughter is rescued and he's on a life sentence or worse, death row, what a great Father he is. Meanwhile the actual bad guy/gal of the story is killed because she is against Christianity. Ok she's a lunatic, but so he Jackman's character. As a UK citizen, i am glad Christianity doesn't automatically mean you are a good guy here, sorry U. S, you need to get some better ethics.
As stated, i watched this when it first came out and liked it more, but since then iv'e grown up and good acting is simply not enough for me to get into the film, i have to empathise with the characters, and this time round, i simply didn't.
I won't explain the story because it's old and as this has spoilers, you probably wouldn't be reading it for plot, but i would say the plot is decent enough, but not enough to override my complaints. I know there are people that say there is a deeper meaning behind this, but i didn't see that, so either i am missing something or they are seeing something that isn't there.
To conclude, the acting alone gets this the 5 stars, but it could have been much better with a different screeplay.
2 out of 6 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Tell Your Friends