I really wanted to like this movie. It just, in my opinion, was awfully done.
-The 3d effects were awful. Maybe if I'd seen it in 2d I would've stayed in my seat longer, but in reading one review it said the opening sequence about the beginning of the universe was worth admission alone. I don't think so. Anyway, throughout, the screen was dark, at many times I wondered "What am I wearing these glasses for, there doesn't seem to be 3d", nothing was coming out of the window and there wasn't much depth.
-Ryan Reynolds doesn't play the f*&# up too well. Plus, how can he have no fear and be a test pilot for a huge company while at the same time being so irresponsible. And overall he looked weird in this movie. He was off his game.
-Also, as I'm not big on GL's backstory, I thought, "Am I going to have to remember all of this different space stuff or can I dismiss it?" This might seem stupid, but I thought this movie would be more grounded. I thought the space stuff would just set up GL's powers and then we'd be on earth for most of the time. It so happens that the only GL stories I've read are like that (older stuff). Now, after I left, maybe that was the case, maybe. And maybe that could have only given us just another superhero movie with different power sets, but I think audiences would've liked it.
-Too much CGI. And it didn't feel like good CGI. Even the beginning, on that lost planet. All of those characters looked goofy, too cartoony. The point of no return was when GL was walking around in his uniform for the first time on that CGI planet. He didn't even look human. His whole body looked CGI. And he was so buff he almost looked like a lady--with breasts and a big butt. Even when it wasn't necessary, there was CGI in this movie. When GL first touched the lantern and his face and eyes got all wonky? Goofy, not cool.
-Character design. First, let me say that I love the GL uniform (except for the nose bit). It would've looked better had the people in them looked better, but they didn't. The bird/fish guy was just insanely goofy looking. And the guardians looked like wizened old smurfs. And Sinestro? He looks like the devil, his name's Sinestro, and we're supposed to believe he's a good guy? (Although, that guy was a great actor--great voice.) Overall, I think these characters and the CGI sets worked against this movie. It was hard to take anything seriously.
-Too much exposition. Why didn't they interest us in the characters first. Like Hal and Carol. The space stuff should've been toned down, and been part of a larger arc, maybe culminating in the third film, while GL dealt with more earth-based problems.
-Poorly written: even the human drama was poorly done in this movie. The family history of the Jordans was overwrought, as was the family dynamic at the birthday party. Poorly executed: it seems like whenever this movie should've taken a right, direction-wise, it took a left.
At that scene on the CGI planet O I asked my boyfriend if he wanted to leave, and he said yes. Outside, I asked him at what point did he first think of leaving. Right away, he said. I couldn't help but agree. (And I usually like space stuff--like Trek.) As a comic book nut, I'm depressed. Even if Captain America does well, GL's bombing will affect the future of comic book movies. There goes ever seeing some of the B-list characters in the DCU. Or, maybe not. Hopefully, all the guys and gals who make movies and write about movies will realize--audiences aren't sick of comic book movies, we're sick of bad comic book movies.
For any disappointed GL fans, you might feel the way I did after seeing X3. But, I never guessed then that in just a few years later we'd have X-Men First Class. So don't despair, you never know what can happen. Maybe GL will do overseas and there will be a sequel, and it will be a great, great movie.
-The 3d effects were awful. Maybe if I'd seen it in 2d I would've stayed in my seat longer, but in reading one review it said the opening sequence about the beginning of the universe was worth admission alone. I don't think so. Anyway, throughout, the screen was dark, at many times I wondered "What am I wearing these glasses for, there doesn't seem to be 3d", nothing was coming out of the window and there wasn't much depth.
-Ryan Reynolds doesn't play the f*&# up too well. Plus, how can he have no fear and be a test pilot for a huge company while at the same time being so irresponsible. And overall he looked weird in this movie. He was off his game.
-Also, as I'm not big on GL's backstory, I thought, "Am I going to have to remember all of this different space stuff or can I dismiss it?" This might seem stupid, but I thought this movie would be more grounded. I thought the space stuff would just set up GL's powers and then we'd be on earth for most of the time. It so happens that the only GL stories I've read are like that (older stuff). Now, after I left, maybe that was the case, maybe. And maybe that could have only given us just another superhero movie with different power sets, but I think audiences would've liked it.
-Too much CGI. And it didn't feel like good CGI. Even the beginning, on that lost planet. All of those characters looked goofy, too cartoony. The point of no return was when GL was walking around in his uniform for the first time on that CGI planet. He didn't even look human. His whole body looked CGI. And he was so buff he almost looked like a lady--with breasts and a big butt. Even when it wasn't necessary, there was CGI in this movie. When GL first touched the lantern and his face and eyes got all wonky? Goofy, not cool.
-Character design. First, let me say that I love the GL uniform (except for the nose bit). It would've looked better had the people in them looked better, but they didn't. The bird/fish guy was just insanely goofy looking. And the guardians looked like wizened old smurfs. And Sinestro? He looks like the devil, his name's Sinestro, and we're supposed to believe he's a good guy? (Although, that guy was a great actor--great voice.) Overall, I think these characters and the CGI sets worked against this movie. It was hard to take anything seriously.
-Too much exposition. Why didn't they interest us in the characters first. Like Hal and Carol. The space stuff should've been toned down, and been part of a larger arc, maybe culminating in the third film, while GL dealt with more earth-based problems.
-Poorly written: even the human drama was poorly done in this movie. The family history of the Jordans was overwrought, as was the family dynamic at the birthday party. Poorly executed: it seems like whenever this movie should've taken a right, direction-wise, it took a left.
At that scene on the CGI planet O I asked my boyfriend if he wanted to leave, and he said yes. Outside, I asked him at what point did he first think of leaving. Right away, he said. I couldn't help but agree. (And I usually like space stuff--like Trek.) As a comic book nut, I'm depressed. Even if Captain America does well, GL's bombing will affect the future of comic book movies. There goes ever seeing some of the B-list characters in the DCU. Or, maybe not. Hopefully, all the guys and gals who make movies and write about movies will realize--audiences aren't sick of comic book movies, we're sick of bad comic book movies.
For any disappointed GL fans, you might feel the way I did after seeing X3. But, I never guessed then that in just a few years later we'd have X-Men First Class. So don't despair, you never know what can happen. Maybe GL will do overseas and there will be a sequel, and it will be a great, great movie.
Tell Your Friends