Let's leave religion out of the review (except for my note at the bottom). As a movie, Noah was both spectacular and a letdown to me.
The first half of the film was the best. Basically, the setup is way better than the payoff. The prophetic dreams, the angels, the building of the ark and mounting tensions were all awesome. Noah is 100% bad-ass with the Creator leading him and backing him up making all that we see really cool.
Then, we get to the ark in the water. It starts off with the excellent narration of creation visualized by the evolution of the Earth. While it uses the visualization of scientific evolution, we still end up with the Biblical (and perfect) Adam and Eve. The fall of man is depicted very faithfully to the stories. This is probably one of the best sequences of the film.
The whole last section (pretty much the second half of the film) went downhill for me. We don't see Noah's visions anymore. We don't know if he's going crazy or is the Creator is still commanding him. Basically, Hermione is preggers, and Noah believes the Creator says he has to kill the baby when it's born if it is a girl. Lots of drama goes on. But, at the end she has twin girls and Noah realizes he can't murder the babies. Then we see the dove with the olive branch in its mouth, which seems to indicate Noah is still acting within the Creator's will.
I guess I didn't like the second half because it became more of a different movie. The first half is pretty straightforward with the audience as far as what the Creator wants Noah to do. In the second half, all of a sudden the audience is left in the dark, and it's unclear whether Noah is still acting on the Creator's behalf. It's a little too much of a bait and switch.
Oh. The angels were rad.
Overall, I'd still say to check it out. It has some cool concepts, and maybe you'll like the second half better than I did....
-------------------------------------------------------------------
My thoughts on the religious adaptation: It's obvious a non-believer adapted this. Yes, other adaptations like The Ten Commandments and The Passion of the Christ made changes while adapting the material, but the reverence for the source material is clear. This movie doesn't seem to be made with the same reverence, but I'd still say it is respectful of the source material. At the end of the day, the changes did not offend me in any way....
3 out of 9 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Tell Your Friends