I'd like to firstly say that I've only watched Episode 1, and that is what my review is based on. In a way, it is the most important episodes of any show, and such, should be so good it sucks me in. It didn't really. I'd also like to say, I went into it with a free and open mind, ready for a different perspective.
The problem I had was simply the fact that I was always bored. Much happens, and a lot of places are visited, and we meet a lot of characters, the problem is you just barely care for what's going on because most of it just seems banal and the writing is so boring. The halfling scenes especially. I mean, what even was that? Gypsy hobbits literally spending decades talking about useless boring fluff and berries... I mean, jheez. I also found myself bored and also confused about the main characters. I just don't care about Elrond or Galadriel, and I think that is because of poor writing too. I also feel casting for some characters weren't great, and a lot of scenes didn't even feel like LoTR, but rather like something out of the Witcher or others. Like the inn scene in that dump of a village. So it all feels a bit, "eh?".
However, it's not totally awful, so I disagree with the 1 ratings. And it isn't "phenomenal", like all the fanboy/overly excitable kids giving it a 10. It's just, alright. If watched all three original films in cinema as a kid, and I tried to not let those masterpieces influence my opinion. It's just, when you take something so magical and full of heart and love, and then see something that is meant to be one billion dollars worth of love and it's just so underwhelming, you can't help but compare and long for some of the magic form the old trilogy. It gets a 5 but an extra 1 star for effort.
The problem I had was simply the fact that I was always bored. Much happens, and a lot of places are visited, and we meet a lot of characters, the problem is you just barely care for what's going on because most of it just seems banal and the writing is so boring. The halfling scenes especially. I mean, what even was that? Gypsy hobbits literally spending decades talking about useless boring fluff and berries... I mean, jheez. I also found myself bored and also confused about the main characters. I just don't care about Elrond or Galadriel, and I think that is because of poor writing too. I also feel casting for some characters weren't great, and a lot of scenes didn't even feel like LoTR, but rather like something out of the Witcher or others. Like the inn scene in that dump of a village. So it all feels a bit, "eh?".
However, it's not totally awful, so I disagree with the 1 ratings. And it isn't "phenomenal", like all the fanboy/overly excitable kids giving it a 10. It's just, alright. If watched all three original films in cinema as a kid, and I tried to not let those masterpieces influence my opinion. It's just, when you take something so magical and full of heart and love, and then see something that is meant to be one billion dollars worth of love and it's just so underwhelming, you can't help but compare and long for some of the magic form the old trilogy. It gets a 5 but an extra 1 star for effort.
Tell Your Friends