With the release of "Superman Returns" in theaters, the question is inevitably asked, 'Is it the best comic book movie ever?'
As badly as I want to say 'yes', I really, -really- am finding comfort in the answer, "Batman Begins has TOUGH competition."
...That will at least answer your question of whether or not it's good.
::The Good::
-Brandon Routh is an excellent Clark Kent/ Superman -Kevin Spacey is an excellent Lex Luthor -Kate Bosworth actually makes for a good supporting lady, much better than Katie Holmes in "Batman Begins" -The effects are TOP-NOTCH, awesome action sequences and near seamless cuts of Superman himself. -Great cinematography. Certain shots try to achieve certain results, and achieve them, they do. -The music is STILL riveting and the Superman theme is timeless. God Bless You, JohnWilliams. -Great writing, believable and fluid character arcs. -There is, in fact, an ace Spider-Man 3 trailer before Superman takes flight...awesome.
::The Bad::
-The last 30 minutes seem to go nowhere, in terms of plot, except telling us that certain characters happens to be alive (oops, plot spoiler). -It's over.
::The Overview::
Is this the best comic book movie ever made? I truly think that is a matter of personal taste. Whether you like the dark, haunting grittiness of Batman or the uplifting, triumphant omnipotence of Superman, "Superman Returns" and "Batman Begins" are equals in their own rights. "Begins" lands a little smoother than "Superman" at the end of the film, but "Returns" features truly human characters, intense, heart-pounding situations and a bumbling Clark Kent as opposed to the smooth, night-stalking Bruce Wayne.
Your choice. Either way, yes, this is a damn good movie.
As badly as I want to say 'yes', I really, -really- am finding comfort in the answer, "Batman Begins has TOUGH competition."
...That will at least answer your question of whether or not it's good.
::The Good::
-Brandon Routh is an excellent Clark Kent/ Superman -Kevin Spacey is an excellent Lex Luthor -Kate Bosworth actually makes for a good supporting lady, much better than Katie Holmes in "Batman Begins" -The effects are TOP-NOTCH, awesome action sequences and near seamless cuts of Superman himself. -Great cinematography. Certain shots try to achieve certain results, and achieve them, they do. -The music is STILL riveting and the Superman theme is timeless. God Bless You, JohnWilliams. -Great writing, believable and fluid character arcs. -There is, in fact, an ace Spider-Man 3 trailer before Superman takes flight...awesome.
::The Bad::
-The last 30 minutes seem to go nowhere, in terms of plot, except telling us that certain characters happens to be alive (oops, plot spoiler). -It's over.
::The Overview::
Is this the best comic book movie ever made? I truly think that is a matter of personal taste. Whether you like the dark, haunting grittiness of Batman or the uplifting, triumphant omnipotence of Superman, "Superman Returns" and "Batman Begins" are equals in their own rights. "Begins" lands a little smoother than "Superman" at the end of the film, but "Returns" features truly human characters, intense, heart-pounding situations and a bumbling Clark Kent as opposed to the smooth, night-stalking Bruce Wayne.
Your choice. Either way, yes, this is a damn good movie.
Tell Your Friends