Firstly, the qualifier statement: I have never watched an episode of the "new" 'Doctor Who', though I saw half an episode in the late 1980s with an old Doctor hiding from long-legged machines that trawled the landscape. Scared the heck out of my six year old self :-) I just sat through the entire first season of 'Torchwood' and I'm feeling disappointed and embittered. I am bloody sure that the creator (RTD?) said that 'Torchwood' was a separate show from 'DW' (ie I wouldn't need to know 'DW' mythology) but I'm confused by who knows what and how. Where did the semi-tamed perydactyl come from... and go? They had a bottle of perydactyl-sauce laying around so they try to attract the predatory bird on occasions, but why? Why wasn't its disappearance referred to later? I'm GUESSING (due to the lack of explanation) that the bird could fly in and out of the rift... so wouldn't it be able to fly above Cardiff too? Why wasn't it caged like a Weevil if it wasn't fully tamed? If it is tamed, where does it perch? These are just my perydactyl questions! There's a temporal/spacial rift running through Cardiff (some place in Wales, I'm Aussie and didn't even know that Wales was a part of Britian... or is it the UK?); the rift is centered in the abandoned (and fictional) Torchwood subway station... so the most top secret, special ops division in the Queen's Country actually CALL themselves Torchwood?! They're named after the publicly-known hub wherein their secret headquarters are located? I'm not upset about the stupidity, it's just so funny! There is also a super cool hidden-in-plain-sight entrance to Torchwood in front of the water feature; that sadly isn't used after episode Cyberwoman. There is a rift machine hidden within the water feature! And Owen knows how to use it! But doesn't know that a part of the machine is missing! And no one in this most secret Black Ops division even comments on the fact that this piece of their uber-powerful machine was A) Missing and B) In Balis' possession.
And why did Balis steal it if he couldn't activate the machine himself? Why didn't they notice the piece was missing? Why didn't the intruder alarm alert these mondo-elite secret service agents that the dangerous Rift machine was compromised? How could Jack forgive Owen for KILLING him? Shouldn't Owen be in deep military trouble? When did Ianto fall for Jack? Why wasn't Ianto Retconned for bringing a dangerous cyborg into Torchwood? And how did he sneak it in? How did clueless Gwen get a job as Second in Command of Torchwood; she was a cop with no weapons experience! What I am trying to say is that I understand British television doesn't have 22 episode seasons - Red Dwarf had six episode seasons. But whilst watching TW S1, I felt like there were episodes missing. Or that the episodes were written by writers who weren't talking to each other. Apart from the pilot, the episodes didn't feel like continuous steps in a story. Apart from that affair, you could mix the episodes up without affecting any plot or character development.
For example: Gwen joins a seriously dangerous and top secret organisation dealing with the manifested consequences of a temporal/spacial rift and we saw no 'learning curve', she hits the ground running and we don't get to learn WITH her; no specialist training in dealing with the alien species, just lessons in gun usage. And how the hell did such a spineless and over-emotional little girl get accepted into such a supposedly elite and vital operation as Torchwood? I'm referring to Countryside and her silly "I need to know WHY Jack!" tantrum, followed by more crying when the cannibal said that he acted this way because he "enjoyed it". Firstly, as an "experienced" cop she would have dealt with child abusers, rapists and paedophiles who say the same so what was with her breakdown about the answer, and secondly, what INTELLIGENT woman (and COP) lets (gives permission to) a SOCIOPATHIC CANNIBALL to lean forward and whisper into her ear! He could have bitten it off you IDIOT! And the way Owen threw her into that tree wasn't "hot"; it wasn't sexual tension; it was violent sexual harassment! I guess I'm saying that there is a dearth between ADULT and INTELLIGENT. The overusage of sex and swearing doesn't bother me in the slightest, it is just there to earn the "adult" tag... but the first season of Torchwood was not intelligent. In trying to portray 'realistic people with human weaknesses we could relate to', the Torchwood writers screwed up by creating characters so emotionally immature and mentally dangerous that they can't function. Shooting each other (Owen KILLING Jack in particular!) do not emphasize tension or thrilling twists... it takes away the tension and suspense because these characters are not powerful enough, nor effective, adults capable of defending Earth against such dangers.
And why did Balis steal it if he couldn't activate the machine himself? Why didn't they notice the piece was missing? Why didn't the intruder alarm alert these mondo-elite secret service agents that the dangerous Rift machine was compromised? How could Jack forgive Owen for KILLING him? Shouldn't Owen be in deep military trouble? When did Ianto fall for Jack? Why wasn't Ianto Retconned for bringing a dangerous cyborg into Torchwood? And how did he sneak it in? How did clueless Gwen get a job as Second in Command of Torchwood; she was a cop with no weapons experience! What I am trying to say is that I understand British television doesn't have 22 episode seasons - Red Dwarf had six episode seasons. But whilst watching TW S1, I felt like there were episodes missing. Or that the episodes were written by writers who weren't talking to each other. Apart from the pilot, the episodes didn't feel like continuous steps in a story. Apart from that affair, you could mix the episodes up without affecting any plot or character development.
For example: Gwen joins a seriously dangerous and top secret organisation dealing with the manifested consequences of a temporal/spacial rift and we saw no 'learning curve', she hits the ground running and we don't get to learn WITH her; no specialist training in dealing with the alien species, just lessons in gun usage. And how the hell did such a spineless and over-emotional little girl get accepted into such a supposedly elite and vital operation as Torchwood? I'm referring to Countryside and her silly "I need to know WHY Jack!" tantrum, followed by more crying when the cannibal said that he acted this way because he "enjoyed it". Firstly, as an "experienced" cop she would have dealt with child abusers, rapists and paedophiles who say the same so what was with her breakdown about the answer, and secondly, what INTELLIGENT woman (and COP) lets (gives permission to) a SOCIOPATHIC CANNIBALL to lean forward and whisper into her ear! He could have bitten it off you IDIOT! And the way Owen threw her into that tree wasn't "hot"; it wasn't sexual tension; it was violent sexual harassment! I guess I'm saying that there is a dearth between ADULT and INTELLIGENT. The overusage of sex and swearing doesn't bother me in the slightest, it is just there to earn the "adult" tag... but the first season of Torchwood was not intelligent. In trying to portray 'realistic people with human weaknesses we could relate to', the Torchwood writers screwed up by creating characters so emotionally immature and mentally dangerous that they can't function. Shooting each other (Owen KILLING Jack in particular!) do not emphasize tension or thrilling twists... it takes away the tension and suspense because these characters are not powerful enough, nor effective, adults capable of defending Earth against such dangers.
Tell Your Friends