Reviews

2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Not for mass audiences, HOWEVER a very clever, funny original
22 October 2012
This film will find its audience among fans of dark comedy. Don't expect the broad appeal of "Shaun of the Dead" or "Hot Fuzz", and comparisons to other Simon Pegg films miss the point. This is a film deserving attention, especially for writers and the "cult" audience who enjoy quirky, unique dark comedies/mysteries.

Reviewers forget that some films are not for everyone, and their opinion is worth nothing in the evaluation of such films. This one may be very much enjoyed by a smaller audience, even after several viewings. "Fantastic Fear" ranks among the "love it or leave it" types; you may find it annoying or too odd, like "Dark Shadows", or it's tremendous fun.

"Burke & Hare" also divided audiences, yet this film has more in common with murder-mysteries, like a cross between "Clue" and a spoofy take on say, the recent "The Raven (2012)". Better than both films, IMO, this will live on with DVD and Blu-ray releases, thankfully.

Box office numbers and critical "consensus" are ultimately short-lived, and very deceptive. Give this a chance if you like dark comedies. And it must be said that Simon Pegg's acting resume becomes increasingly impressive. Regardless of the final product, you have to give him props. And here, the final product is better than you might expect.
70 out of 86 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Best of its kind since "The Shining"
30 December 2011
I stayed up the night before it's VOD release to watch right after midnight. I've been waiting a good year for this: another Ti West movie, and a genuine ghost story on a haunted property--no monsters or goblins or mind-tricks. Horror fans, we tend to roll our eyes at "ghost" stories, yet they tend to be my favorites even though the greats are very few.

This is the most well-made AND entertaining film of its kind since "The Shining". Had to see it again this morning. Glad it's a 48 hour rental, because it's likely to get a third watch.

P.S. Another example of a great product falling through the cracks at the big studios. The majors will now play catch-up, as West has re- invigorated the "paranormal"/"supernatural" horror film.
10 out of 27 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed