Change Your Image
jennifer-137
Reviews
Cold Mountain (2003)
Blech. Read the book instead.
To be fair, I rarely like a movie once I've read the book, and this is especially so with a book I loved as much as Cold Mountain. So those of you who haven't read it should take my comments with a grain of salt.
One of the best things about the novel was the lack of schmaltz. There, the relationship between Ada and Inman was secondary to Inman's travels and Ada's coming into her own -- yet always there was the potential for love. Focusing on the character development -- and hinting at this potential -- made sense because Inman and Ada really didn't know each other before their separation, yet through the years each developed in a way that could only add to their compatibility. I looked forward to their reunion knowing that it had become logical for them to be together. That's romantic. In the movie, however, it was presented as a given that they were each other's "aine true love" -- yet Minghella never did the heavy lifting of creating scenes that showed them actually getting to know each other -- just blushing and making googly eyes. So really all we knew is that they found each other hot. Instead of Inman clinging to the notion of Ada as "home," and Ada finally arriving at the mature conclusion that she wanted to be with Inman, we saw a lot of pining after each other to the swelling of syrupy music. Please! If you want to see a true romance, watch Minghella's MUCH superior "Truly Madly Deeply."
Truly Madly Deeply (1990)
touching portrait of a real relationship
This is a beautiful little movie. Juliet Stevenson (as Nina) plays one of the most authentic female leads I've ever seen: She bawls full-out, complete with fluids; she looks like a man in bad lighting; she's passive aggressive and irritable and loveable and likeable and real. Likewise, Alan Rickman's character, Jamie, is peevish, like all of us, self-centered, like all of us, but beautiful and unique and again, real. Unlike the schmaltz we're fed here in the states, where dialogue consists of rehearsed speeches (think Jerry Maguire) and love seems skin-deep, this is a couple that seems not only to love each other but to genuinely like each other; a couple that has their own language, as long-term couples do (and it's not translated, which is so refreshing), a couple that can be silly with each other and irritated with each other within minutes; that can have spats that are not high drama or the beginning of the end or anything other than the end of a long day in a too-hot apartment. The ending broke my heart yet seemed like the most natural and right course of action. Truly stunning.