Change Your Image
dijl
Reviews
Marion Bridge (2002)
Three Sisters in Nova Scotia
Marion Bridge was one of 14 films nominated for the Tiger Awards of the International Film Festival Rotterdam 2003 and I wouldn't be at all surprised to see this film win. I have deep respect for the actresses who play the three sisters Agnes, Theresa and Louise, especially for Molly Parker (Agnes aka Angie). Mother is dying in the remote village in Nova Scotia where the sisters spent their youth. Agnes, who has an alcohol problem (inherited from her mother, as it seems), returns from Toronto just to find nothing has really changed. There is the usual bickering with her sisters, the woman next door is as nosy as ever and the people getting drunk in the local bar seem to have never left the building. A notion of suspense is triggered as Agnes repeatedly parks the family car in front of a souvenir shop. There she sits and watches the young girl Joanie who lives there. As the drama slowly develops questions are answered and new questions launched, even after the plot is unveiled. I won't give it away here, but I can assure it is quite shocking. The three sisters are very well cast as is their mother. The father who lives with another woman is an old sod who doesn't seem to remember (or care) what has happened in the past. Marion Bridge ends with an optimistic scene which is as moving as the film as a whole. A noteworthy achievement by young director Wiebke von Carolsfeld.
Lagaan: Once Upon a Time in India (2001)
Slow, but enjoyable, like a game of cricket
I enjoyed this film very much. It is a classic story in which the underdog eventually triumphs over his suppressors. Colonial times revisited, and hard times they were for the villagers in India where the film is set. The British demand more tax ('lagaan') to be payed, but since a drought has plagued the country there is hardly enough crop for the farmers to survive. They are desperate. What to do? Hopefully a game of cricket will change their fate. The villagers select a team that have to defeat the British who of course think themselves Goliath. It is a game against all odds. Should the villagers win, they won't have to pay 'lagaan' for a period of three years. Should they lose, they will have to pay triple the amount. The three day cricket game in the film is portrayed very convincingly. I watched 'Lagaan' on dvd with two cricket fans like me and we thought the cricket scenes were very realistic. The story develops in a slow manner but that does not raise any objections, for in a way the duration of the film (225 minutes!) reflects the pace of life in 1890's rural India as well as the course of a decent game of cricket. There is ample song and dance in the film as well which sort of gives it an oriental 'Sound of Music'-like pretension. The dance scenes are well-orchestrated and quite enjoyable, though they tend to hold up the story too much. I suppose this is very Bollywood. To summarize: yeah, I like 'Lagaan' a lot!
The Man Who Wasn't There (2001)
What can go wrong, will go wrong
The story of this Coen Brothers film resembles that of 'Fargo': man in need of cash schemes plot; plot fails; man ends up being arrested. In this case he is executed in the electric chair. That serves him right, for people died thanks to his wrong doing. But is he a criminal? By definition, yes. Though to the viewer he is more like a decent civilian who was tempted to take the wrong path and can't go back. Even when he tells the truth -- while his wife is serving in jail for the murder he more or less accidentally committed -- he is not believed by the classy lawyer he has hired. His wife hangs herself, so the case is dismissed. After he is linked to another death, he lands in jail and in afore mentioned chair. He is to die for something he is not guilty of, but accepts the verdict to pay his debts. The film is in black and white which adds to the 'film noir'-character. Note that 'The man who wasn't there' is not the first Coen Brothers film in which hair or hair treatment plays a major role. In 'O Brother, where art thou' there is this crook who is more concerned about his hair than about his general well being (and that of his confrères). Here the man is a barber in a small town barber shop. Before the execution one of his legs is shaved, a scene that in a macabre way mirrors the bath tub scene in which as a loving husband he shaves his wife's legs. A typical Coen Brothers film with great playing by Billy Bob Thornton. And what a smoker he is! Do the Coen Brothers know the 'sadistic universe' of Dutch literary writer Willem Frederik Hermans? Same as in their films, in his books anything that can go wrong, will go wrong. It is Murphy's Law, as well as Coen's and Hermans'. It would be great to see a Coen Brothers adaption of Hermans' 1966 novel 'Never sleep again'.