I felt sorry for Patrick Stewart playing Scrooge. I felt this actor tried hard to be his own Scrooge, but he missed by a mile. I felt his acting was forced.
But I felt the rest of the cast played it well, and Richard E. Grant as Bob Crachet was superb in his role.
Particularly at the end when Grant picked up a poker to defend himself against his evil boss, Grant was shaking, terrified of his boss, and the atmosphere this one scene created, was for me very powerful.
I suspect this is how every homeless person feels today against those among the British public who behave just like Scrooge, they could not care less, and many homeless people are spat upon.
Those among the British public who behave like this are a disgrace, and they frighten the homeless, just like Grant's Bob Crachet was frightened into picking up that poker.
It is a shame that in my opinion Patrick Stewart was unable to provide his Scrooge with the same menace.
I felt the story was flat, almost boring. I give it 2 out of 10 for a good effort.
But I give Richard E. Grant a full 10 marks for his role, and his wife and children equally so, they were all excellent.
The best Scrooge films by far, is the Alastair Sim version, and the George C. Scott version.
George C. Scott's version is more applicable to today's Society where the homeless people are under the Bridge, and the man asks his wife, "why cant I work to provide for my family", this question was spot on for today, because it reflects today.
And then when George C Scott realises everything, he kneels down and asks, "what have I done" ?, because he realises how mean and short sighted he has been.
And I would say "what have I done?", can also be said of those in our Society that have their heads in the sand, not realising and not caring about anybody but themselves, or the consequences of their actions.
4 out of 9 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Tell Your Friends