Reviews

2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
A one in a million film which portrays an issue felt by many.
29 December 2001
"When a man loves a woman" is a truly terrific film that allows the audience to interact with the emotional struggles of all of the characters particularly Alice, Michael and the children. Every emotion is conveyed with such effectiveness and a realistic portrayal of the struggles of a family torn apart by addiction is allowed to be told without sensationalism. It is not, as some suggest, information based without any entertainment value. Rather this film confronts the audience with the fact that love is not perfect, that love is a all in all whirlwind of emotions that are unpredictable and complex.

It was a surprising performance by Ryan who usually fulfils the predictable role in a romantic comedy. Garcia, as usual was brilliant, his characters demand a presence on the screen and he does not disappoint.

The helplessness of both Alice and Michael is played out well. Further the portrayal of Alice having an addictive personality that is fueled by alcohol is also convincing. This idea emerges in the scene of the eggs being thrown over the car, which is often criticised by others in these comments. This scene did have a role to play and aligned with others that suggested that Alice thought that she was only loved when she was doing something fun and crazy. Being boring was something very much feared by Alice.

This film is a psychological drama with the essential element of romance to assure the complete attention of its audience. Great film, Great cast.
9 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
a must see for all hsc students!
3 December 2001
Being that i am one year out of the HSC i watched this movie remembering what i was feeling. I recall all that josie struggles with, expectations, a social life and the bitchiness of high school (it's all there trust me!!). Anyway, this movie really did a great job exploring the journey of Josie, the realisation that she comes to in discovering that you cant plan everything or really anything. The issues dealt with were particualy relevent, specifically Johns suicide. However, perhaps this relationship could have been developed a little more before his death. Overall this movie is a winner, a great story that understands teenagers of this generation, and the expectation that they are under to know exactly what they are going to do with the rest of their life, at the age of 17/18. A great cast that really made this story come alive.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed