Of course not having enough source material from the original but not very long novel didn't help. But then again the other three years did fine with the same handicap. But in season 4 they had to get all woke and subsequentially silly.
First off, they introduced the BCR, or the Black Communist Rebellion, some Noir Panther knock-off. Of course the audience got yet another lecture how bad even the pre-Nazi America was to blacks, yadda yadda. But they were also presented as about the only resistance to the Japanese on the West Coast, even though in the beginning of the series there were plenty of white resistance fighters on the West Coast. And as opposed to the case in the Nazi occupied zone where whites of Northern European stock could work for that regime as equals, all non-Japanese were treated as inferiors in the "Japanese Pacific States" or JPS. So no one else was fighting the Japanese except the BCR in season 4, which seems like total nonsense when it goes against even the 1st season. Also they created this totally dishonest victims backstory for the bleeps in season 4 where they were almost all exterminated by the Nazis in the East in Auschwitz style death camps, which didn't happen in real life or in the book. In the book they were re-enslaved but not exterminated.
They even took that to the east coast where the Julia's resistance squad was hiding out in a vacant Harlem neighborhood where the houses of the blacks were untouched after they were taken away 20 years earlier. So whole neighborhoods in New York City Manhattan, now the capital of Reich America, were ghost towns nobody used or even entered to scavenge and loot? You'd think that such valuable Manhattan real estate would be scooped up ASAP. In real life the houses and possessions of the Jews and other enemies of the Reich were taken as spoils by everyone else left behind, starting with Party members. Then Julia's plan to meet up with Helen Smith was harebrained too. They send one guy who was previously assaulted and threatened by Helen's super girl Nazi minder Martha to be chased down again and forced to commit suicide by Martha in a department store, thereby alerting the Reichsmarshall to a possible threat to his wife. Julia schedules a secret rendezvous with Helen at a women's clinic later on where she meets Helen Smith dressed up as a nurse. For background Helen already knew Julia and knew she was in the resistance; so there was previous trust established. So instead of talking privately in the doctor's office behind a locked door, she leads them both down to the basement where Wyatt dressed up as a janitor was on hand to guard. So super Nazi minder Martha gets suspicious, tracks them down and almost kills Wyatt with her Nazi dagger before Julia helps Wyatt to do her in. But super Martha seriously messed up Wyatt because super women are the norm? The Flick Filosopher would ban me for disparaging that meme. So they not only burn Martha and her stuff, but throw her knife into the handy incinerator too, so later on Gestapo agents can track Martha's fate down. But why Helen and her protection team even left the clinic in the first place w/o Martha and how none of the other Nazi guards noted that is a cheap plot hole. The gist of the meeting was that Julia told Martha that an alt version of her dead son Thomas was alive on the alt world where the Nazis lost and the Smiths were just ordinary middle class American nice folks. Why they had to go into the basement to tell Helen that is beyond me.
I liked the alternate world part that the Nazi portal in the Poconos led too. Julia was able to travel to alternate worlds without the portal and she ended up in the Nazi lost the war for the beginning of season 4 where she met the nice Smiths. But she noticed the Nazi interlopers were sabotaging rockets and killing scientists in that world and when she realized they were coming after her too, she magically went back to the Nazis won world to get back into the resistance. The Nazi interloper ended up killing the alt John Smith instead of her as he saved her from the killer. So according to the portal rules laid out, John Smith was now able to go to the alt world and meet up with the alt Helen and the alt Thomas, which he did later on. But he met the alt of an old Jewish US Army buddy whom he sold out when he turned Nazi in his Nazi world. Reichsmarshall John Smith was a US Army Signal Corps general in WW 2. He tried in vain to keep alt Thomas from enlisting in the 1964 US Marines because he felt he'd get killed in Viet Nam. He used some heavy anti-war rhetoric to stop his son from enlisting in the USMC, and between that and meeting up with the alt of his old Jewish Army friend must have caused him to reconsider his sordid present as Reichsmarshall John Smith. Another problem I had with the portal was the Nazis had Dr. Mengele run it. He was a freaking Biologist and Geneticist, not a Physicist or Engineer. I guess the show runners' thinking must have been that Mengele's name would be recognized and jeered at by lots of people, while hardly anyone would know a name of an actual contemporary German Physicist even Heisenberg.
But back to the JPS and west coast: The BCR set off a bunch of bombs targeting the oil pipeline which eventually caused the Japanese to withdraw because things were going bad in their war in China and they needed the oil. So the Emperor decides to abandon their super valuable west coast colony because they need the oil? Don't the Japanese still control the oil in Java and how will they insure the new west coast government there will still send them oil? No one said Japanese were losing on the sea since the US Navy wasn't around to sink their warships and supply line tankers after the US lost. They were just tied down in China. So a few bombs set off by the bleeps were all that it took to get the Japanese to leave. I guess no one heard of the fanatical and horrible fights to the death, no-surrender defensive battles in the Pacific like Iwo Jima and Okinawa. The Japanese got backed into a large corner by a few guerillas and saboteurs so they leave en masse. That is totally unrealistic plot point. Then the only white resistance we see in season 4 aside from Wyatt's part in an assassination attempt he did solely to get arms for his people in the east from the BCR, was some lame white vigilantes who came around in vain TWICE to kill Kido, the Kempetai chief. Kido gets a chance at redemption, why? Maybe because of his son who has PTSD from horrible things his soldier son did in Manchuria to civilians, as if the Japanese didn't commit absolutely horrible acts of brutal mass murder against the Chinese from 1937 onwards like their soldiers individually raping, shooting, bayonetting, clubbing, burning 250,000 poor Chinese civilians in the Rape of Nanking. Nor did the real life Japanese even try to hide their brutality, they bragged in their press about contests among their soldiers to see how many Chinese they could behead in a day. So only his son had trouble with such normal and horrific Japanese army behavior. Kido also supported the Navy who wanted to abandon the west coast and that caused the navy to run afoul of the army, which was a realistic plot point based on the idiotic rivalry between their two services in WW 2. There was a lot of time devoted to some boring subplot to redeem himself by trying to save his son from the Yakuza after his son went rogue from PTSD. You see Kido was too hard and unfeeling towards his son, as if that wasn't the norm then. So the show has to lecture the audience on how to be a better father, dull?
Now back to the Nazis on the east coast. Reichsmarshall John Smith and his German partners in Germany kill off Himmler and his cronies and the new fuhrer give John Smith and the American part of the Reich co-equal status. While no one minds John Smith killing off Heinrich Himmler, why they had to drag J. Edgar Hoover as in the FBI in as an American turncoat head of the American Gestapo to kill him off as an enemy of John is a sordid attempt to score political points with the liberals. Then let's go back to the whole portal thing. They show Reichsmarshall John Smith travelling to the portal, built in an old Pennsylvanian coal mine, on a rocket powered monorail train. How freaking retro Sci Fi kitsch is that? Monorails never went past amusement park ride status for very simple reason is they are TOTALLY impractical. Yeah, that alone is a sore spot. Since this review is listed as having spoilers, I will tell you that Julia and the now recovered Wyatt along with a whole battalion blow up the elevated line and kill Reichsmarshall John Smith, and his wife Helen dies in the crash. Their assault team also takes over the portal. Upon learning of Reichsmarshall John Smith's death, his immediate successor tears off his swastika and recalls the invasion force that was ready to pounce on the west coast. Meanwhile the portal opens up and random people come streaming in from alt world.
I don't how that is even possible, since in the other alt world, the one like ours, the portal just appeared as a random old mine entrance in Pennsylvania. And if it was discovered on the other world, wouldn't they send in a team of armed formal emissaries/explorers to scout things out at first? I guess these random interlopers are supposed to represent the hordes of illegals that the show runners want us to embrace. In short the 4th and final year undermined the whole series.
5 out of 7 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Tell Your Friends