Reviews

6 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
Stranger (2015)
6/10
Puzzling melange of history, artistic scenery and absurd humor
26 October 2017
Warning: Spoilers
Although this was the first Kazakh movie I've seen, I had somehow a strong feeling of familiarity.I guess this was due to the resemble of Kurosawa's breathtaking wild nature scenery in combination with an awkward humor, which appears in the second part of the film.

The plot begins in a serious, dramatic note, picturing the hard life of the orphan Ilyas, who, like a modern Tarzan, escapes into a life of isolated wilderness in the mountains. Strangely enough, he thrives in the environment, building a home into a cave, hunting beasts and breeding domestic animals, while his village is ravished by war's horrors.

The director takes a very explicit point of view against Russian communism, which becomes the background in the second part of the film. I'm addressing it as the second part, although there is no distinct split, because there is a brutal shift from the drama to an awkward, absurd humor, which goes up to paroxysm in the scenes depicting Ilyas' nightmare.

Also it's worth mentioning that the director condiments the whole film with shamelessly conspicuous emotional extortion, almost cliché- istic. For instance, upon his death, we see his life's memorabilia: his only memory from his late father- a trinket, which has the Menorah engraved (?!) or the doll from his childhood lover.

To be honest, I didn't truly understand what the director wanted to achieve with this film, because it was a melange of history, artistic scenery and absurd humor, in a carousel of emotions.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Sensitive love story
3 September 2011
Warning: Spoilers
Wow, how come there are no reviews for this film?!...It is one of the most sensitive love stories I have ever seen on screen. The fantastic premises of living your life in just one day and experiencing every thing in life just once and that the Hell is a life with days repeating one after another (how actually life is) is generous, but also sets up high standards for the interpretation. In this fantastic world, two young lovers decide that they want to go to Hell, in order to live their love over and over again. And they go to Hell, but Hell is...hell. Searching, longing, trying to forget about the other.

This film succeeds in sewing such deeply emotional bits, both visual and auditory, that it will bring tears to anyone's eyes instantly. It is depressing in a comfortable way, but above all, it transposes so much delicacy and innocence! I loved it.
15 out of 20 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Carne (1991)
9/10
Disturbing
23 March 2007
Warning: Spoilers
I would say that this film is disturbing. The brutality is depicted in a very sick way, it's like a psychosis in 40 minutes. In the same time, it is a cruel introspection in human behavior. The scenes are ferocious, starting with the butchery of the horse and ending with the brutal sex scene in the kitchen. Every emotion is exploited to extreme, the frustration of the butcher, the love for his daughter almost incestuous, the rage when he finds out she has been abused, every feeling is so natural and so wrong. This film delivers the truth about human nature in a very honest and brutal way. The message of the film is that one's life can change in a second as a consequence of one's behavior and that the most primitive emotions are the most powerful and can determine one's acting. I'd loved the unique manner of filming, the simplicity and the brutality accompanied with the silence in which only inner thoughts pierce through.
14 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Shocking and spectacular
13 March 2007
Warning: Spoilers
Before watching this film, I was quite circumspect regarding the Korean origin. Though, I was intrigued by the fact that the lead actress committed suicide shortly after. In the first part of the film, the plot is rather common- a murder investigation, a policeman's family life, nothing spectacular. But as the plot evolves, it gets more intense. The policeman's life is duplicitous, oscillating between the amenable, newly pregnant wife and a very appealing mistress- the singer Ga-yee. From the time Ga-yee finds out she is pregnant too, everything gets really complicated. She is confronted with Ki-hoon's incapacity to commitment regarding the unborn child and her love for him develops into obsession. In the same time, during the murder investigation, Ki-hoon experiments some sort of physical attraction to the the former wife of the dead man- principal suspect. In a very twisted chance of fate, Ki-hoon and Ga-yee end up locked in the trunk of his car, in an isolated place. The scenes are quite shocking, picturing the raw despair and the dramatic moments are so intense that you almost believe they are real. The paroxysm is reached when Ga-yee has a spontaneous abortion and then begs Ki-hoon to shoot her, which he does. It is worth mentioning that these scenes are very cruel and bloody. The title of the film comes up by Ga-yee's confession that the name she wanted for the baby is Pearl, Hester Pryne's daughter in the novel "The Scarlet Letter" by Nathaniel Hawthorne. I was very impressed of the ending, in my honest opinion, the actors played excellent some of most complex and hard to imitate human feelings. If I should compare this film to other, it would be with "Irreversible".
6 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
An animated short -film about Japan and the blast at Hiroshima
27 February 2007
Warning: Spoilers
This is an excellent short-film directed by Alain Escalle, based on his experience with the Japanese world and culture. It is animated, but in a spectacular way, it has a strong visual impact on the viewer due to scenes full of powerful colors such as red and green alternating with black and white scenes.

There are many symbols present, both of war, famine, disaster and fragility of humankind, love, peace, universal symbols, but also Japanese symbols ( e.g. the dragon). The great soundtrack featuring a Japanese song adds sensibility to the whole view and makes the images even stronger. There is an attention for the details specific to the Asian culture, every element in every scene has its significance and it is carefully picked up and put it there. This film is intended as a manifest against the horrors of the war in general, by presenting the tragedy of Hiroshima. In the same time, there is a journey through Japan history.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
An excellent short-film
27 February 2007
This film is like a surrealistic painting and a poetry in the same shell. The subject of the film is very actual- the flimsiness with which we base our choices in life and in love especially. It's about how people try to appear beautiful and pleasant to others, it's about our insecurity and our crave to be loved and appreciated by others. There is a french delicacy in every scene, in the music, maybe a little humor, a ingenious combination of time dimensions. The visual art is overwhelming, due to the 4 years spent to make this short-film. "Homme sans tête" has a charm which remains after you've seen it. For me was a totally surprise and a joy in the same time.
6 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed