It sucks to delete my original review. It was over a thousand words, and ten times the minimum review length. But I have to rewrite it.
Centaurworld season one is a fantastic exploration of a phenomenon we understand as Barbenheimer. A culmination of the grim and the glow. The light and the dark. It mixes the jovial and comical tone with a slice of some real darkness. Eerie songs permeate the show, and there's a lot to see. It's flawed for certain. It's not exceptionally paced, the voices could be recast here and there, and a few songs aren't quite right. Overall though, season one was a funny show with a hell of a lot of personality
Centaurworld season two should be studied in a laboratory for how absolutely it failed the show. The tone set by the first season inherently flows magnificently into a second if capitalized upon. Season one started with a dark and edgy opening, moves into a sickeningly silly world, and forces the characters to adapt. Over time, after the guard has been dropped, it begins to reintroduce that edge and bleakness until a culmination in the finale, hinting at more to come. In an ideal world, season 2 would have carried that momentum forward. The centaurs in Centaurworld need to mature, just like Horse needed to ease up. There's a middle ground in which a character already exists; Wammawink. She has a depressing backstory and fits the tone perfectly. However, the rest of the main cast never matures. The rest of the season never matures. It stagnates in its childish tone, rather than challenging it. Nobody grows into the best person they can, taking the maturity of the human realm and the joy of Centaurworld to a place they can coexist, only the main character who did it in the first season.
Even outside of the lack of growth, the second season is just bad. It's not as funny, the arcs are mostly unsatisfying (minus like, one thing Durpleton does), and episode 2 is the most insufferable episode of a TV show I've ever seen, it sucks, I hate it. Not only that but, spoilers for the finale, it's not satisfying. Rider SHOULD have died to leave a lasting impact, y'know, show some balls please show, and Elktaur shouldn't have. He should have been forced to survive and attone for his sins, right the wrongs he caused. Both sides of him he became ended up as the worst of his personality. It shows how trying to live half a life makes the other half resent you, and you resent it back. Denying a part of yourself is self destructive. But he needs to pay. Even if he has to die, have the gaul to show it. Don't just show the spear of ANOTHER character who got NO development this season do it OFF SCREEN, commit to it. Kill him on screen. Show us. I know it's a kids show, but you can show Rider getting stabbed through the stomach here. You can kill a on screen.
Every problem this show has is proven and surpassed by a recent cartoon great, Amphibia. The villain isn't killed, but he has to attone. The characters got satisfying arcs. Character got stabbed through the chest and it actually had impact on the viewer. Hey, if I had a nickel for every time a female lead character in a modern western cartoon got stabbed in the chest by a character people used to think was a good guy and ultimately live thanks to some ex machina bs, I'd have two nickels.
You can say I take myself too seriously. It's a cartoon about magic bubble characters in a magic bubble world. But the show itself proves it wants to be MORE. Season one it shows much more. It has great music, good jokes, and a great premise. I wish I could give this show an 8, or even just a 7, but every year that passes the lower and lower this show gets. Season two had an ace and a queen and folded.
5 out of 14 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Tell Your Friends