I really, really did not want to like this show. Most fans treat it like it's the only good piece of media ever made, and over analyze every small detail like any hand motion an actor makes must be a metaphor for the American Dream.
And the writers also are often unbearably pretensious especially regarding anyone trying to understand what's going on with her show. One actually got angry people watch it with subtitles bc they're apparently doing it wrong trying to understand the words in the often very time and area specific slang.
But that being said... It's an excellent show. Wouldn't say it's the best of all time but you'll understand from the beginning why it has garnered such a devoted fan base and lauded critical status.
What the show does best is nuance and intertwining numerous stories and characters together. I haven't seen many crime dramas that do such a great job making every situation and character a shade of grey instead of black and white.
The criminals are multi dimensional people, with good and bad aspects to who they are. Doing terrible things but also having their own sense of morality and loyalty. The cops are shown to be a mix of basically being a legal gang filled with corrupted and self serving people and ones that genuinely are trying to clean up their community.
The dialogue is also very well written. It's believable and interesting, it all feels very human. And due to how many characters and stories are happening and it's avoidance of spelling things out the show is consistently engaging, rarely ever feeling like anything is filler.
And it tackles its themes and situations with an often genius level of complexity. Handling the idea of police corruption, gang life, poverty, beurocracy, morality, etc with expertise.
You'll be loving a character one second, then hating them another, and then sympathizing with when right after as the balance of being human is done at a level that most series are unable to produce.
But I do think there are faults to the show. It's adherence to not spoon feeding or spelling out things is very admirable but also aggravating at times. I have no clue how people watched this on syndicated television, I need subtitles and a recap article often and I'm streaming the show.
Could have assumed not everyone would want to spend that much energy to enjoy an entertainment product; it's a show not a job. Especially when many viewers are not familiar with the type of city and situations the show is based on is recreating.
It can also kind of be really up its own butt when using metaphors and analogies. For writers who love to self congratulate on their subtly and lack of making things simple they really do love dedicating minutes of a scene for these.
Like someone explaining how to play chess as a metaphor for gang life; aren't the writers so smart for using the most cliche analog for violent hierarchies???
I don't know, maybe that wouldn't bother me if the show wasn't treated with pretension by many who view or worked on the show. There may be a reason it's still not as discussed as many of its contemporaries when everyone involved seems antagonist to general audiences enjoying the show.
But all that aside it's a brilliant piece of media and still holds up today. Definitely give it a watch.
1 out of 2 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Tell Your Friends