I had not seen this film until recently and had no great expectation that I would think it the masterpiece its supporters claim it to be- the reviews suggested dullness.
It is slow. An old married couple visit their grown up children who all live in Tokyo, the visit is not quite a success as the sons and daughters are all too concerned with their own lives to pay that much attention too notice their mother is a bit unwell and the dad, a laconic figure who appears to be a bit boring, only really enjoys himself when he meets up with some old mates and drinks a bit too much sake. The mum dies shortly after she goes home The film is slow, nobody speaks witty lines and there are no punch-ups. But it is never boring even if some of the characters are. The dialogue is, for me, a touch too clipped but that is a small cavil. It is an absorbing film which led this viewer to think about funerals, post-War Japan and how despite cultural differences the Japanese family presented here seems not unlike most families I have known - they love each other but can get bored with each other too and even in the superficial trauma of an unexpected death little differences are still there and new hierarchies forever forming.
Ozu had a very deliberate style of filmmaking - the only other one of his films I have seen, Brothers and Sisters of the Toda Family, was made a dozen years previously and it too employs the same style of filming indoor scenes with a static camera with the actors seldom being quite in the centre of the frame. Rooms are seldom symmetrical and there are few, if any, close-ups. And yet there is an intimacy in most of the shots all the same. It should be stagey but it is not, instead Tokyo Story is a superb portrait of what a family is like.
I do not know that Tokyo Story is one of the greatest films of all time, better according to Sight and Sound polls superior than anything Scorsese, Bergman, Wilder, Kubrick et al ever made. Filmmaking is not the Premiership or the Masters' Golf- it should not be a competition to be better than some other work. Tokyo Story is not a bundle of laughs and it never grabbed me by the lapel trying to persuade me it's a great film. But it is a Great Film.
It is slow. An old married couple visit their grown up children who all live in Tokyo, the visit is not quite a success as the sons and daughters are all too concerned with their own lives to pay that much attention too notice their mother is a bit unwell and the dad, a laconic figure who appears to be a bit boring, only really enjoys himself when he meets up with some old mates and drinks a bit too much sake. The mum dies shortly after she goes home The film is slow, nobody speaks witty lines and there are no punch-ups. But it is never boring even if some of the characters are. The dialogue is, for me, a touch too clipped but that is a small cavil. It is an absorbing film which led this viewer to think about funerals, post-War Japan and how despite cultural differences the Japanese family presented here seems not unlike most families I have known - they love each other but can get bored with each other too and even in the superficial trauma of an unexpected death little differences are still there and new hierarchies forever forming.
Ozu had a very deliberate style of filmmaking - the only other one of his films I have seen, Brothers and Sisters of the Toda Family, was made a dozen years previously and it too employs the same style of filming indoor scenes with a static camera with the actors seldom being quite in the centre of the frame. Rooms are seldom symmetrical and there are few, if any, close-ups. And yet there is an intimacy in most of the shots all the same. It should be stagey but it is not, instead Tokyo Story is a superb portrait of what a family is like.
I do not know that Tokyo Story is one of the greatest films of all time, better according to Sight and Sound polls superior than anything Scorsese, Bergman, Wilder, Kubrick et al ever made. Filmmaking is not the Premiership or the Masters' Golf- it should not be a competition to be better than some other work. Tokyo Story is not a bundle of laughs and it never grabbed me by the lapel trying to persuade me it's a great film. But it is a Great Film.
Tell Your Friends