I binge-watched the episodes in a single day. I didn't know anything about the case or what was the final verdict, before watching the show. There were so many live footage of the prison time, interview with relatives all dating back to the 80s and it seemed as if it was all being played live.
There were so many twists and turns, interviews with the Israeli Judges who gave the initial verdict in the 80s, interview with the prosecutor, the defense counsel, the live court recordings, etc.
The different documentary proofs brought by the Israeli prosecution included witness testimonies of the few surviving Treblink holocaust survivors against a man who they believed was 'Ivan the terrible', a war criminal who was probably the most cruel and dangerous Nazi of all, responsible for the death of more than 800,000 Jews. This was probably the only court case in Israel of which a live record was shown on tv and radio and closely followed by everyone in the country. The testimony of the 3 or 4 survivors was pure heart breaking. One cannot imagine the horrors on their families and on fellow Jews, which they saw in the Nazi death camp.
On the other hand, there was the sole defense counsel from Israel who was kind of fighting against his country and against all odds by defending a war criminal accused arguing that it was all a case of mistaken identity. He even had acid thrown on his face during the trials but continued to fight the case. There were documentary evidences showing that probably it was a case of mistaken identity and maybe he was not 'Ivan the terrible'?
Two points that made me think:
- Can a person who was actually responsible for the killing, torture and other unspeakable atrocities on Jews, on human beings that is, change his nature so drastically such that after he migrates to the US and in all the 40 plus years there.. is known as a kind, family, church going, law abiding man? Is it possible that his actual self would never have emerge during the 40 odd years?
- Could the Treblink holocaust survivors actually recognise the man they confirm is 'Ivan the terrible', after 45 years? 45 years is like a lifetime and one's thoughts can get blurred and even the actual perpetrator would have had such drastic changes in their facial and body features. Could they have correctly recognised him?
Somehow I feel the verdict by Israeli Supreme Court was the correct one and the one in German court after 10 years was also right.
So Netflix again comes up with a great documentary series where you learn much about history and one that makes you think long after the show is over. An absolute must see.
16 out of 45 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Tell Your Friends