Writing Credits (in alphabetical order)
| Emmy Blotnick | ... | (writer) |
| Michael Brumm | ||
| Greg Iwinski | ||
Cast (in credits order)
| Stephen Colbert | ... | Self - Host | |
| Tony Shalhoub | ... | Self - Guest | |
 |
Joe Wong | ... | Self |
| Bryan Cranston | ... | Self - Guest | |
| Laura Linney | ... | Self - Guest | |
| Rachel Dratch | ... | Self | |
| John Oliver | ... | Self | |
| Nick Kroll | ... | Self | |
|
|
Django Gold | ... | Self |
| Rest of cast listed alphabetically: | |||
| Jon Batiste | ... | Self - Musical Director | |
| Stay Human | ... | Themselves - House Band | |
| Molly K. Lyons | ... | Molly | |
| Michael P.J. Marston | ... | Kids Pitch / Self | |
| Tyler Bourke | ... | Kids Pitch (uncredited) | |
| Gabriella Sophia Terrero | ... | Gabriella in Kids Pitch: Christmas Movie (uncredited) | |
Produced by
| Ballard C. Boyd | ... | field producer |
| Michael Brumm | ... | producer |
| Neil Goldman | ... | segment producer (segment "producer") |
| Monica Hickey | ... | segment producer (segment "producer") |
| Harris Mayersohn | ... | associate producer |
| Jami McGuigan | ... | associate producer |
| Jonah Meyerson | ... | associate producer |
| Nick Vasile | ... | segment producer (segment "producer") |
| Geraldyne Wee | ... | associate producer |
| Keith Zubrow | ... | associate producer |
Makeup Department
| Lani Barry | ... | makeup artist |
| JT Franchuk | ... | key hair stylist |
| Kerrie R. Plant | ... | makeup department head |
| Ron Wolek | ... | wig maker: Santa Claus |
Camera and Electrical Department
| Hillary Knox | ... | lighting programmer |
| Constantine Leonardos | ... | moving light programmer (as Costa Leonardos) |
Costume and Wardrobe Department
| Merav Elbaz Belschner | ... | wardrobe (uncredited) |
Music Department
| Josh Levitt | ... | music clearance |
Additional Crew
| Erik Akerblom | ... | technical maintenance supervisor |
| Sean Fahey | ... | production staff: CBS Page |
| Kristin Feinberg | ... | Talent Assistant |
| Billy Gleeson | ... | assistant production coordinator |
| Olivia Sanabria | ... | field production assistant |
| Shakira Saunders | ... | researcher |
| Cami Thacher | ... | researcher |
| Rachel Voter | ... | social media manager (uncredited) |