"Atlanta" Sinterklaas Is Coming to Town (TV Episode 2022) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
17 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
Great episode but poor research
dirkjan-3531317 August 2022
Warning: Spoilers
Amazing that they're able to take te same "Atlanta vibe" all the way over the ocean. It's nice to see all the beloved characters back in the way we used to, really makes me look forward to the rest of the season.

The "black pete" part on the other hand is nowhere near reality. Especially in Amsterdam it's actually not done nowadays.
13 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
This is what we've been waiting for!
themcbear-7687825 March 2022
Great episode, really funny, shocking and intriguing this show never fails to be creative and I can't wait to see where the rest of the season goes because this and the first episode were great.
27 out of 38 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
I think I'll just skip this season
nerrdrage20 August 2023
Playing catchup in 2023. This episode felt off, and I think it's the geographic change. This show runs on a very delicate magic and I think being in Atlanta is part of that magic. Atlanta is a character in the show, maybe the true lead character. Not that I've ever been there, but the character of the place really shines through.

A lot of people are chiding the writers for not doing research about Black Pete but don't they get that this show is surreal and not mean to always be taken literally? Last week we had a lake full of zombies, cmon. The black Pete stuff is what Earn etc feel like just from seeing one kid in blackface. Then they feel like everyone around them is in blackface.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Sinterklaas is old
R-Ronteltap17 April 2022
Okay, as a Ducth guy, actually living in Amsterdam, I did find this episode funny. But please know that while Sinterklaas with "black pete" is still done for children in some parts of the country, it is never-ever done in an adult-only setting, and certainly not at pop concerts. Note: I'm not "pro" it, but this is an artistic exaggeration.
65 out of 75 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
You can the show out of Atlanta, but you can't take Atlanta out of the show
reynoldswraptpe26 March 2022
Warning: Spoilers
R. I. P. "Tupac"

This was every bit as good as Atlanta has always been. Y'all just trippin. I can't wait to see where this is all going.

Also, Darius watches Foodfight and considers it "intense" (It's not)
40 out of 48 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Atlanta at its best
lmanjones26 March 2022
Warning: Spoilers
SPOILERS:

Everything about this ep is great. Showing the racist history of some of the European traditions like black pete. Van finding herself and having a character arc instead of being just a romantic interest for Earn. The Tupac scene was terrifyingly hilarious. Donald is a genius. Couldn't of asked for more. I like how Earn is actually becoming a better manager slightly. The guy beating up the kid in black face thinkings it's Earn was the perfect ending for this masterpiece of a follow up to a such a dark opening episode. Rip devonte hart and the rest of the hart family who episode 1 was based.
26 out of 37 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
WTF!?! That hiatus was worth it...
thedooog26 March 2022
Just 5 werds for yaz, Food Fight WTF!!!!!!! All I need to say. But apparently need 150 characters to express all that needs to be said about the episode. This episode and the one before it are sharp af . Cuts you down the funnbown and cuts you down the heart. Very well done.
14 out of 20 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Sinterklaas Is Coming to Town
lassegalsgaard16 May 2022
A fun fact: the roommate I had at the film boarding school I just graduated from actually worked with the woman from the opening of this episode. She was in one of the student films that he was a part of while at the school. So, while I never actually met or even know this woman, I've been in contact with someone who has worked with her, which is super awesome. That was just a little fun story that doesn't really have anything to do with this episode, but anything that almost connects me to "Atlanta" is worth talking about here if you ask me. The episode in itself is apparently inspired by ASAP Rocky being detained in Stockholm and the nice time he had while in a Swedish jail. That's just a small part of the episode, which largely deals with the Dutch holiday tradition known as Sinterklaas, a tradition that has been called racist by many, including members of the Dutch population themselves. So, leave it to this show and its incredible writers to come up with a funny premise for an episode that deals with this heads-on. If you do that, you'll end up with something like this, which isn't a bad thing. This episode could have easily been the opener of the season and opened it all up to a big a bang as the premiere did, but for some reason, having this episode as No. 2 makes it so much more satisfying to spend some more time with these characters.

It's been difficult not to get some time with these characters that we've grown so connected to over the course of the first two seasons, but this episode brings them all back together in team-ups that I didn't know I really wanted. It feels like the writers never put them out of their mind as they find themselves in situations that they could have easily been caught up in had they been home in the same frames of Atlanta. However, now they're in Europe on a tour and they find out that stuff is just as weird here as home.

I was a little bit afraid that the show would lose its charm when it went away from its main setting. However, the writers are not afraid to mess with the outside world and add a lot of their usual charm to the boringness of our days in Europe. Wherever these characters go, weird things will follow. And Sinterklaas is the perfect opportunity for the writers to put the characters in those weird and uncomfortable situations, despite the episode actually spending less time with it than I thought they would. However, it does lead to a highly entertaining climatic scene.

The writers also decide to bring Darius and Van together in their own little adventure, which takes the audience to a very dark place. It felt like the classic darkness that "Atlanta" is so good at bringing up, mixed in with that dark humor that they love so much. In other words, it was a perfect scene for this show, but it also managed to surprise me. I thought I had the scene figured - which includes an awesome callback to the very first episode of the show - but they quickly proved me wrong, showing that they're much smarter than me.

All the characters go through important progressions in this episode. It feels like Van is being put more firmly into the weirdness through her interactions with Darius, giving her a clearer view of what this show actually is. At the same time, Earn and Alfred are feeling the success of their story at the moment, which gives them a lot of fun development. However, as happy as their time is right now, I'm sure that something will come along to rip that away from them. As long as the charming performances from the entire cast remains untouched as they are.

"Sinterklaas is Coming to Town" delivers a perfect premise for this show and ends up becoming another show high point. It deals with the racial themes that they've always touched on and it doesn't skip a beat in introducing us to the characters that we know and love from earlier.
3 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Respect the rebrand
dannylee-7808210 February 2023
Warning: Spoilers
1. Earn is late 2. Al is in jail 3. Tupac gets choked

So we are formally introduced how our beloved characters are doing in season 3. It seems like they are better off - Al and Earn seem like they've made their mark in the European scene, getting 20k in advance and staying in fancy hotels. Earn still seems to maintain his character - being comfortable in the role of a manager but seems somewhat disconnected and fatigued (which his continuous sneezes imply). It also seems like Earn and Van have drifted quite a bit but why Netherlands? Why would she come to where Earn is and stay there? They have some complicated but realistic relationship going on and it's one of the less "surreal" parts about the show.

Speaking of surreal, this episode recreated what we saw on Atlanta to Netherlands with utilizing the tradition of "blackface". I actually watched a youtube shorts about this recently so the timing was convenient. It is an interesting tradition that I think can easily be offensive to some. Not all traditions need to survive. The whole thing with Tupac's death scene was so funny and shocking at the same time. Van seems like she's going through a lot and I hope they include her more in this season.

A great lighthearted start to the show. It's good to be back.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
A SPIKE LEE JOINT
douglasjordane22 June 2022
THERE IS SO MUCH PAIN THAT WE CAN MASK WITH HUMOR. WHILE THIS EPISODE TOOK US ON QUITE ANOTHER UNEXPLAINABLE ODYSSEY, I WAS INTRIGUED BY THE CINEMATOGRAPHY OF IT ALL, AND THE SCENE STRUCTURE SEQUENCE. IT WAS LIKE A MALE VERSION OF NOLA DARLING. SCENIC AMSTERDAM EVOKES A LITTLE SPIKE LEE IN ALL OF US.

I APPRECIATED THE CINEMATIC GENIUS ENOUGH TO GIVE THIS EPISODE A TEN BUT I BUT I GAVE IT A 9 INSTEAD, UNEXPLAINABLY. BESIDES, I COULD NOT READ THE TEXTS, SO A BIT OF THE MESSAGE WAS NOT CONVEYED.

9 OF 10 STARS.
0 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Returning to something familiar
Criticalstaff10 May 2022
While the first episode felt more like an inside joke, this episode the show returns to a more familiar format. Except, and that is the whole premise of this season, the characters are evolving in a somewhat different environment: Europe.

It is different yet recognizable. European-ness is used primarily as an exotic backdrop. Obviously since this is an American show for Americans watching American TV. It is not really an exploration of European identity or racial relations in Europe; or one would could have hoped, black identity in the US versus elsewhere. This season, it feels more like window dressing for the show's core themes. Which remain largely the same: black identity and the experience of being black. As I write that, I am unsure if I could have formulated that as "the black experience". Which is incidentally also a theme of the show: white guilt.

What is relatively ambitious is that the show completely sheds any concept of plot and focuses mainly on the characters emotional responses to these very peculiar self-contained scenarios. It does not mean that there is no plot or story in the narrowest definition. Yet, the plot of each episode and the story at large it supposedly tells is insignificant. It does not really matter what happens or what are the consequences. The actual reason why they are in Europe is barely mentioned or acknowledged (to a certain extent it is implicit, they're there for Paper Boi's European Tour). There are no real link between these stories. It is more a succession of vignettes of slices of life. Slice of life of a semi-famous rapper of course, whos is on tour in a recognizable yet strange land.

In this Amsterdam episode, we follow two plots. One goes through an exaggerated confrontation with Zwarte Piet and the other with a ridiculous religious wake of sorts. The episode's strength is not necessarily the social commentary rather than the ability to balance seriousness and genuine emotion with over the top goofy gags. You end up with something that is equally brilliantly funny, profound, disturbing, and mesmerizing.

It is an episode where there is nothing really to see here. Yet, I had a good time watching it. Nothing noteworthy happened, yet I do not feel like I wasted my time.
3 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Wow, Donald, done any research?
kruiwagen200028 March 2022
Warning: Spoilers
I just want people to know: blackface as depicted in this episode is wildly exaggerated. Yes, "Black Pete" (people in black face) was an integral part of the Dutch "Sinterklaas" celebration and you still see it in rural areas in the Netherlands, but in Amsterdam as in all other dutch cities this is, after years of intense debating over the racist origins of Black Pete, not done. The character is now displayed by people with some smudges on their faces, not the stereotypical blackface as you see in this episode. Certainly you would NEVER see adults doing this and certainty not people just walking around, going to a concert or even working (like the cleaning lady and the bell hop) in blackface. SHM man. I get that it is comedy and supposed to be absurdist or whatever, (the "cult euthanasia' certainly was absurdist, I hope people will get that this is also not done in the Netherlands?) but this displays Dutch people as completely oblivious. I don't get why nobody apparently told the makers of this show. This is commentary to a racist custom decennia too late.
57 out of 115 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Slow and born
GhostReturns26 March 2022
Very difficult to watch. 30 mins felt like 3 hours. Story was not interesting. Character dialog dragged on and was not interesting. What happen to Darius? Are we to believe a kid from ATL developed into that in a short span. Also why is Van there again? Shouldn't she be in ATL looking for a job taking care of her daughter and new boyfriend.
25 out of 139 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
The show used to be great, then it started trying too hard...
vc8113 October 2022
The first two seasons were fantastic. But then after many awards and acclaim, it started to take itself too seriously and the narrative was changed. The first episode was intriguing enough for season 3 but then it just kept going down hill for me. You really stop caring about the characters and aren't as invested anymore. The political statements in each episode are also just not hitting the mark anymore. While I will say the first two seasons are some of the best on TV, the latest aren't and it's good that it's ending because I think they seriously ran out of ideas after season 2 and just lived on hype the rest of the way.
6 out of 24 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Unfortunate sensationalist depiction of Dutch
kevrosm10 February 2024
I think Atlanta is brilliantly clever and funny but this episode was off. A theme in the show revolves around the commodification of Black culture in the US, the height of that is seen at the end of S01. So it's ironic that the show would do this exact same thing to Dutch culture.

I've lived in Amsterdam for 10 years-no one puts on black face for Sinterklaas. And the aggressive promoter? That's hardly how people in NL would react. It's laid back almost to a fault. The prison scene was based on a story from Sweden. That's a different country and people. And Franz, well that's a cliche name for a German, not a Dutchman. It wouldn't merit mentioning but so much of this episode is built on cliche and so I think it was actually just poor research into a generalized Dutch first name.

I don't think it matters too deeply that these details were off. It's a TV show stretching reality to make it's point. And Dutch people are chill.

But it does make one ask a question of the show runners about the principals of artistic license.

Is it ok to suspend or exaggerate cultural reality in favour of story and theatre in the depiction of one group and not for another?
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
What show is this
wandasvision26 March 2022
Slow and Boring. Not good at all and why aren't we in atlanta :( like Darius is a completely different character? They're all playing themselves at this point as well.
15 out of 118 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Meh
rippajackson26 March 2022
Another super boring uninteresting Episode, if episode 3 is anything like the previous 2 episodes I shall be rating this show a 3/10 and calling it a day. Season 3 so far is a mockery compared to the previous seasons which might I add, were fantastic.
14 out of 164 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed