User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
The Funny Façade of Film
swimslikelead21 January 2008
As two disillusioned flat mates – the consciously plump producer Trudy Jones-McCrone and the thinly talented actor Luna Sea – attempt to propel themselves into the filmic limelight, their equilibrium is upset by hierarchies, selfish actors, lunatic writers, and an unscrupulous director, Vic Young. The journey that they are both about to undertake will test their faith in their art, human nature and, above all else, each other.

As a self-styled black comedy, this film within a film adopts 'The Office'-style documentary approach that contains some genuinely funny Scots' humour that covers the width of the spectrum, from polished wit to bodily function gags. The premise of the film itself is interestingly layered as it depicts just how difficult some find the process of writing films, having that film made, and then exhibited; this is interlaced with the trials and tribulations of a struggling actor's life and all the upheavals that vocation brings.

As an obviously ironic piece from independent filmmakers themselves, one is forced to wonder just how much of this feature comes from elements of the Finnigans' own personal experience. Duncan Finnigan, as the dodgy film producer Vic Young, shows that he is clearly more talented than his camera operating background alone; in this type of role he is in his element and his improvisations contribute enormously to the comedy element. The film narrative itself seems adamant – no matter what life may throw at you – that pursuing your art is imperative, even if there are "36,000 unemployed actors" out there or your best ideas are Star Trek meets Philadelphia and pitched as "aids in space"!

Another dimension to the piece is the personas that the struggling actor, Luna, adopts; he writes his scripts verbatim from the situations and people around him – yet paradoxically in his portrayals of other people he seems at his most uniquely gifted as an actor, and as such his character asks questions of whether anything can truly be original anymore.

As a comedy the film works well, even if the jokes may be deemed a little low-brow by some. The film offers some sharp editing and an intertextual homage to film noir, comics, and the docu-soap; it is worth a view as a comment on artistic (art, film, music) endeavour alone and although the narrative is conventional, it is far removed from mainstream concerns.

The film itself may be seen as a humorous façade within which hides the unsavoury nature of not just the film industry but life itself as it covers lies, adultery, betrayal, and the futility of placing faith in others – inevitably prompting one to question whether things actually will work out alright in the end.

In an industry where the mainstream is rapidly dictating the way of the art, this light-hearted comedic romp is a valuable reflection of how those in positions of funding power take precedent over creative content– a concern this particular film is always going to avoid.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
You could almost love to hate it . . .
Chris_Docker25 September 2007
Warning: Spoilers
I watched the first five minutes of My Life As A Bus Stop in sheer delight. At last, I thought, here is some original, side-splitting Scottish humour. Our characters all want to get into film-making and - shame! - no one is recognising their self-proclaimed talent. Trudy is the well-spoken larger lady who wants to make a film about larger ladies. Luna Sea (lunacy - geddit?), who sounds as if he just fell off the bus from a suburb where no-one uses words of more than one syllable, is her lodger and flatmate. Luna Sea is an aspiring (as opposed to inspiring) actor who writes his own scripts. Luna's dad is a rock 'star'. Marlene is a young, relatively normal girl aspiring to be an actress but who also can't get a part for love or money. Although Luna claims she will sleep with anyone who offers her one. Lastly there's Vic (played by director Duncan Finnigan) who is a wacky would-be producer. Vic will even sleep with Trudy if he thinks she will fund his project.

The characters are, intentionally, all grotesque caricatures. Luna, although seemingly short on brain cells, nevertheless has the street-smarts to con Trudy. All of them con themselves into thinking they are endowed with great artistic flair. They look down on anyone else in the business who refuses to support their inflated egos. Even a chap from the Edinburgh International Film Festival gets short shrift when he comes into the pub where Luna works (I'm reviewing the film for its premiere at the festival and cringe slightly - Luna is not someone I want to meet on a dark, damp street late at night!)

But what works brilliantly as a short sketch falls into difficulties as a feature film. Most of the movie is made up of relatively unconnected incidents in the lives its protagonists. An ingenious con - where Vic gets a man with learning difficulties to be abusive to Trudy - works quite well, even if you find it politically incorrect in retrospect. And Luna's dad is full of surprises, emphasising that the oddball people in this film are remarkably different and all interesting in themselves. But Luna's endless attempts at his 'bus stop' sketch, the pulled faces and whining about not being appreciated can easily begin to irritate more than amuse.

Where this mockumentary feels unsteady is that the caricatures are pushed too far with insufficient material. Although there are no doubt housing estate wannabees like Luna, or clueless acting teachers such as the one at his class, the film fails to connect to the idea that today there are myriad highly trained, aspiring actors, directors and producers. People with masters degrees in film studies who aren't offered jobs.

This would not be a problem as far as our film goes if there were sufficient humour to fill another hour and half. But once the initial idiosyncrasies have been absorbed, the film becomes repetitious and some contrast would have been welcome. Intellectually-challenged characters can be amusing for a short time but the entertainment value wears thin without a suitable foil. Developing Marlene more, for instance, could have provided a funny man's straight girl for the main players to bounce off (a standard device for this type of pleasurable craziness). The unbelievable ending, although providing a welcome change of tone, is too convenient and comes too late.

My Life As A Bus Stop is one of those oddities without which no film festival would be complete. There is some inventive photography and gratuitously touristy shots of Edinburgh's castle. Whether you want to give Luna, Trudy, Marlene and Vic your hard earned cash at the box-office will be another matter. I think I'd rather buy the Big Issue. The characters do have an undeniable charm. Luna Sea's face is worryingly burnt into my brain. But isn't fun poked at overweight people and mentally retarded people a bit offensive? It's a film I hate to like. I can't make up my mind. Missing the bus could be the default option. In which case I'll probably end up buying it on DVD next year.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Low Budget High Return
DeepFriedFilm2 November 2007
My Life As A Bus Stop is a fabulous film with some fantastic performances. In correction of the other review the man with "learning difficulties" is inaccurate. He's just gullible, as are most people who are desperate to get into the film industry. We all like to think we won't fall for it, but more often than not we do. This is a recurring theme within the film - with everyone working for free, with the dangled carrot of that big pay day and stardom keeping them going. I laughed whole heartedly at the film, but came away quite depressed too. This is a very funny, but also a very true representation of the film industry in Scotland. Maybe it hits too close to the mark for the industry to laugh at, but people outside the "industry" will find this a funny and bizarre look into the world of low-budget film making.
1 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed