Own the rights?
10 out of 11 people found the following review useful: Well, Not Too Bad., 17 September 2008 Author: linkintown from Nepal
This movie cannot be called a masterpiece but its very intelligently made. The reason, great story. Keeps you guessing until the end. Though the plot is not that clear but the way Kelvin Tong has made this movie makes you watch it till the end. I am a fan of his movie "The Maid" which is another thrilling horror movie.His way of making movie by putting up the sounds really is great.if you are planning to watch this movie you will be thrilled till the end though this kind of movie has been made before.Horror fans, thinking that this movie has lot of brutality, blood, sexual content , I would like to tell you this movie will provide you nothing. Yet you should watch it and feel the thrills . One of the great Asian movies i have seen so far this year.
6 out of 10 people found the following review useful: Worth the ticket price, 2 April 2008 Author: darkmax from Singapore
The story was well-written especially for a topic that has essentially been "beaten" to death by HK movie makers in the 90s. The plot is intelligent but not too clever. There's no mystery about things in the story, nothing that hasn't been seen before.The twist in the end wasn't unexpected, but I found it a tat bit too short and should have been made a little bit clearer.The horror factor of the movie, to me at least, was the use of sudden loud noise/music that is so common these days among this genre.Well, for one who isn't into horror genre, I'll tell you to go watch this one. Don't expect the unexpected though.
10 out of 19 people found the following review useful: A Nutshell Review: Rule #1, 8 March 2008 Author: DICK STEEL from Singapore
I'm sure some of you out there would conveniently associate Kelvin Tong's reputation with the dismal Men in White, forgetting that the writer-director had his success stories in his earlier works Eating Air and The Maid. You can tell clearly that I did not really enjoy MiW, nor his experimental Love Story, but with Rule #1, Kelvin Tong gets my vote of confidence henceforth, if he steers clear of bad comedy, and pretentious art house flicks.What I do like about his movies, each one of them, is how he grips you right from the start. How it develops then on is a different tale, but his introductions are nothing short of mesmerizing. Here, he demolishes all preconceived notions you have when watching a movie, and warns you of sorts about the experience you're going to go through with Rule #1, that is, to throw all assumptions out of the window. In fact, the opening scenes were frantic and leaves you just enough to continue questioning in which direction the movie will propel itself forward.And thankfully, it made all the right moves, despite momentarily lapses in succumbing to cheap scares that don't really add much value to the movie. Yes, we know how Kelvin crafts scenes that will send shivers down your spine until the crescendo (even Men in White's introduction had shades of this), and they all work here too, except that I thought that they were a little unnecessary except to anchor the movie in the land of the supernatural. It's central plot doesn't become clear until midway through the movie, and from then on it lunges to a higher plateau at breakneck speed, with the audience probably second and triple guessing themselves all the way to the finale, with flashbacks at times becoming a little too spelt out for good.It's a smart move to have this movie made in Hong Kong, where he has able crew (Cinematographer Keung Kwok Man lensed the movie and made it look really edgy) and leads like Ekin Cheng and Shawn Yue to carry the movie through. Ekin plays the head honcho in the police force's Miscellaneous Affairs Department (MAD, heh), which handles the 2% of calls synonymous with the X-Files. His Inspector Wong's drunken antics and devil may care attitude seem to stem from his long serving years in MAD, but he survives day to day with his mantra Rule #1 - There is no such things as ghosts - which he imparts to team rookie Sergeant Lee (Shawn Yue), who slowly learns that the mantra and scientific explanations seem to run contrary to what Wong really knows. I thought Yue gave a tremendous performance in his role as the pained Lee in John Constantine garb, who in his second chance at life seemed to have opened his eyes to ghosts who walk on this earth. While scenes where the two male leads play off each other are limited, I particularly enjoyed the one where they staked out their prey, which had them banter on rather matter-of-factly at how they would approach the impending scenario, before their greatest fears come alive, and that rug from under our feet starts to stir.Sure there are familiar shades from movies like Fallen and Suicide Club, and a lot of "waking up" moments, but they never did once mar my enjoyment of the movie as it went along. Rule #1 had enough suspenseful moments to thrill, and Kelvin Tong seemed very assured to be in familiar grounds of horror. Those expecting an all out fright-fest may be slightly disappointed as it turns on the supernatural spin a lot more than the boo-moments, and fans of Fiona Xie will find that their Mediacorp darling still got relegated to a flower vase role in a one-dimensional performance, despite this being her second movie outing (after One Leg Kicking). Here she plays the dutiful girlfriend to Sergeant Lee, and that's about it, being half-asleep most of the time (no, nothing sexy about that too).Mark my words, Rule #1 is Kelvin Tong's best movie to date, and definitely very well executed, as good as or even better than any Asian thriller in recent memory. He has shown again that he can craft commercially viable movies with relatively original stories to tell. Note the release date on your calendar, and give it a go next week!
SPOILER ALERT: Kelvin Tong's "Rule #1", 27 July 2009 Author: ky_chong
*** This review may contain spoilers ***
Spoiler alert: If you intend to watch the movie, do not read this review until you have seen it. :) At the beginning of the end credits for "Rule #1", Kelvin Tong, who co-wrote the script, noted it was based on a true story. I cannot for one imagine how this film can be based on a true story, since the central premise of it is so far-fetched that one has to justify it by saying "This is just a movie." After all, as we all know, thank goodness, "Rule #1" is a fictional film, not real life.The story follows a Hong Kong cop Lee Kwok-keung (played by Shawn Yue) who ends up in the Miscellaneous Affairs Department after witnessing a horrific incident where a corpse kills a serial killer who is about to pull the trigger on himself. Since the HK Police Force does not admit to paranormal activities, he is sent to work under Inspector Wong, the slightly overweight chief (Ekin Cheng) of the MAD. As he goes on with his work, he finds paranormal activities everywhere, and that as a cop, he has to deal with them his own way."Rule #1" is Kelvin Tong's sixth feature, and it is a couple of notches up his 2005 horror flick "The Maid". Here, Tong finally succeeds in writing a script that is original and more interesting than that previously, which relies too much on previous horror films to work. In "Rule #1", horror conventions are still the norm, but it has a story that keeps one guessing. Also, the acting in "Rule #1", from Shawn Yue and Ekin Cheng, are excellent, even though the body count at the end is too much. People who have watched the feature will know what I mean."Rule #1" is also relentlessly depressing, almost in a noirish sort of way, but, to quote from the loveHKfilm.com review which I feel hits the mark, "the film can't support its own far-out premise, and its nihilism feels unearned." The film does sport a massive plothole that will trouble a lot of people, myself included: if these "ghosts" can travel anywhere and in and out of anybody's body, what makes one think that they can be killed in the first place using a bullet? How, in the first place, can they get killed anyway? What will stop them from doing anything they like? (Another plothole: how did Inspector Wong get by shooting dead a small boy?) But if you can just swallow the central premise and get on with the story, "Rule #1" will reward. It will keep you watching until the end. Just don't expect a film that make sense out of its own logic all the time, as in the finest horror thrillers. Recommended, but with reservations.
Add another review
