"Doctor Who" The Ice Warriors: Episode Five (TV Episode 1967) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
"Your not a man your a machine slave." Good story.
poolandrews9 November 2007
Warning: Spoilers
Doctor Who: The Ice Warriors: Five (unusually there's no 'Episode' prefix) starts as the Doctor (Patrick Troughton) tries to convince the Ice Warriors that he can help them leave Earth in their spaceship, they don't trust him & fear the Brittanicus Ice Base's Ioniser which they believe the scientists there want to use to destroy them. The Ice Warriors also learn from the Doctor that the energy used to power the Brittanicus Ice Base could be used to power their dead engines & prepare to storm the base & take what they need...

Episode 15 from season 5 this Doctor Who adventure originally aired here in the UK during December 1967, one of only four episodes currently know to exist from this story after many were destroyed by the BBC during the 70's this was directed by Derek Martinus & has been pretty good so far. The script by Brian Halyes has gone into anti-technology mode as it tries to demonstrate computers are untrustworthy & shouldn't be relied upon because logic isn't always the answer, sometime human intuition, instinct, imagination & risk-taking is needed in a situation. Unfortunately this is far less interesting than the plot involving the Ice Warriors & didn't make much of an impact on me. I also have to mention the resolution at the start of this episode to the cliffhanger ending from the previous one, it's surely one of the worst & most sloppily handled ever. For a start the entire cliffhanger was re-filmed as the camera angles are totally different, also Varga the Ice Warrior boss clearly counts to five & beyond at the end of episode four while at the start of episode five he barely reaches three before the Doctor cracks & simply tells Varga what he wants to know which was the most obvious & dull resolution to the cliffhanger possible. What I'm trying to say is besides being one of the worst cliffhanger endings ever the end of episode four & the beginning of episode five simply don't match each other, originally they were shown a full week apart but in the days of VHS & DVD where you can & almost certainly will see one episode straight after the other it's very noticeable & a bit sloppy.

There has been a real live bear in this episode which attacks Penley & Jamie which the production team probably borrowed from London Zoo. The acting is alright if nothing spectacular, Peter Sallis who appeared in over 250 episode of Last of the Summer Wine (1973 - 2007) & has provided the voice for Wallace in the Wallace & Gromit films plays a scientist here. Trivia note: apparently in his autobiography when Sallis recalls his time on Doctor Who he claims he played an Ice Warrior when he clearly plays a very human scientist!

The Ice Warriors: Five is an entertaining enough way to pass 25 minutes if your looking for for a bit of sci-fi or a fan of the series.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
The Doctor uses his ingenuity.
Sleepin_Dragon24 February 2020
It's a battle of wills as Penley takes on Clent, the computer instructs Clent on what to do next, but Clent insists he thinks for himself. The Doctor and Victoria are held by The Ice Warriors, who plan to attack the base.

It is essentially a base under siege story, but it's so much better than that simplistic tagline. The Doctor is very ingenious, and behaving in the exact way we were all made to believe the character would, combatting his enemies without violence.

It's a good episode, the clash of two very different people, I wonder if the writer was partly psychic, and able to see just how reliant we'd become on computers as time went on.

An exciting penultimate episode, with lots going on, plus a very good cliffhanger, it's very enjoyable. 8/10
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Icy but super hot - this is a fantastic production and a real classic
A_Kind_Of_CineMagic1 September 2014
Review of all 6 episodes:

This is a tremendous production in all respects. The costumes really stand out straight away as superb and believable. They are stylishly and expertly made especially for the humans and also for the Ice Warriors. The acting and characterisation are of a high standard throughout with guest parts well written and acted providing realistic and interesting characters. The Ice Warriors are brilliant, the TARDIS crew main cast are on great form and the script is fantastic. The story itself is great fun with plenty of action but also intelligent and thoughtful science fiction. There are ideas of humans over-reliance on machines, people torn between just running away from a system they dislike or fighting to change it, relationships with aliens (those different to us) and the threat of war and moral questions which result. More than that though it is just a fine example of a very well produced, exciting story with great villains and three dimensional characters.

I really could not disagree more (and frankly do not understand) a review I read on here giving this a very cool (pardon the pun) reception. Everyone is entitled to their opinion but the only direct criticism I could spot in that review was to say this is somewhat copied from the story of The Thing From Another World, other than that they just say it did not grab them. Well if this does not grab you I suggest Doctor Who will never rate well for you. This is top notch Doctor Who, and that is a view supported by its high rating on IMDb and by reviews by Doctor Who specialist reviewers such as the BBC Episode Guide. To say it is like The Thing From Another World is not entirely wrong in that the story contains an alien preserved in ice which is then thawed out but would that reviewer criticise The Brain of Morbius (widely considered one of the best ever stories) because it vaguely copies the premise of Frankenstein?! I am not a fan at all of copying other people's ideas or derivative stories. However, this is not derivative it purely shares an aspect of that story just as the ideas of nearly every science fiction story all share some aspect or other with at least one other story. The Borg in Star Trek for instance are quite close in concept to the Cybermen (and all cyborgs in sci- fi) but it does not make them rubbish because they are done differently enough and are good in their own right.

This story over its 6 episodes has way more going for it and way more ideas than just the alien in the ice premise. It is a perfect example of an alien menace adventure. The only significant flaw for me is a tiny bit of the scientific explanation regarding the ice age in Episode 1.

My Ratings: Episode 1 - 9/10, Episodes 2-6 - 10/10
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed