- Tommy has a new girlfriend - Tiffany, the waitress that Titus had an affair with. Titus is convinced that Tiffany is just using Tommy to get back together with Titus. The truth is actually more paralyzing than that..
- Tommy has terrible taste in girlfriends and Titus feels that he is always saving Tommy from his toxic relationships.
Tiffany, the waitress Christopher slept with in "The Break Up", begins dating Tommy. Erin is angry and she doesn't forget or forgive easily. But Tommy desperately wants them to get along. Erin won't consider it as Tiffany slept with her boyfriend. She believes that Titus's horrible mistake will haunt them forever. Christopher thinks Tiffany's date with Tommy is a ruse to get closer to him. Erin can't believe Titus's arrogance and decides to stay at the dinner with Tiffany to prove Titus wrong.
But Tiffany totally hits on Titus by saying (in private) that he is twice as good as Tommy in bed. Erin won't believe Titus at all. Ken arrives as well and reveals that Titus and Tiffany did it in a car.
Tiffany tells Erin that she slept with Titus when she was at a low point in her life. Tiffany is saving up to go to business school. She is trying to copy Erin and turns out they have both applied to the same college. Tiffany has a kid that Tommy loves. Titus calls out Tiffany in front of everybody, for hitting on him and taking Tommy for a false ride. Titus calls Tiffany a blood sucking Vampire and calls Tommy her day care. Tiffany is upset and leaves.
Erin wants Titus to apologize to Tiffany and promises him physical harm if he doesn't. Titus goes into the kitchen and finds Tiffany having sex with the cook. Titus forces Tommy to go back into the kitchen to have a look himself, but he comes back and reports that Tiffany fell and broke her neck.
When Titus and Erin go into the kitchen, they find Tiffany lying on the floor, flat on her back. Titus thinks she is faking it, drops an entire bowl of salad on her. Titus asks Tiffany to admit how she broke her neck. Tiffany admits to Erin that she was having sex with the chef. Ken and Titus want Tommy to know the truth, but Erin wants to spare Tommy's feelings. But Tiffany tells Tommy herself. Tommy is OK as he has an arrangement with Tiffany. She sleeps with other people, and he can sleep with her. Dave is so excited to hear this that he makes the same arrangement with his girlfriend Nancy.
Titus wants Tommy to break up with Tiffany, but Tommy wants to do what he wants. Titus says that Tiffany is not Tommy's girlfriend, but more like a timeshare. Titus also says that Tommy is normal and stable and he does not need to be like other weird people in the world like Titus himself. Titus convinces Tommy that Tiffany is not right for her and he eventually does break up with Tiffany. Tiffany calls Tommy Titus's puppet and is angry at Titus. Tiffany calls Tommy a loser as she is carried off in a stretcher. Even on a stretcher, Tiffany wants to have a punch off with Titus. Ken advises Tommy to go gay.
Contribute to this page
Suggest an edit or add missing content