"Highlander" Turnabout (TV Episode 1993) Poster

(TV Series)

(1993)

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
Tessa being terrorized again turned me off. Too obvious the thing about Michael. New recurring character introduced. Lazy writing, Mac sent off on goose chases.
reb-warrior8 March 2020
Warning: Spoilers
Quenton Barnes, a serial killer immortal is killing people that were associated with his execution decades earlier. Mac's old immortal friend Michael, shows up. He's tracking Barnes. Barnes killed his fiance decades earlier.

A new recurring character is introduced, Charlie DeSalvo. Charlie owns a dojo that Duncan and Richie go to train at. Charlie is a good guy, but he is also one of the nosiest characters on the show. For some reason, Duncan likes to say "Charlie" all the time. Not in this episode, but keep your ears open for future episodes. In conversations with Charlie, he says his name too often even though his convo is direct with him. Pay attention, you'll see what I mean. It's annoying.

Joe wants Duncan to track down Barnes and "do something" about it. Mac rightly points out he is not a cop. This is the beginning of a long controversial thing Joe does. He is not supposed to interfere in immortal affairs, but he does, and his interfering does indeed gives Mac the upper hand. I mean obviously, we all want Mac to win, but I always had a problem with this because it's almost like cheating. Mac doesn't need to cheat. He doesn't need to have an upper hand. He's already top dog.

It turns out Michael had DID, and he is Quenton Barnes. You'd think the Watchers would have known Barnes and Michael are the same people. I know Barnes messes with the Watcher file. But since Joe knew Barnes was back killing people it seemed odd he didn't know about the second id.

Tessa is once again terrorized by a man, Barnes. Oh boy. They(the writers) just couldn't let her alone. They had to have her be victimized yet again. Honestly, I grew tired of this on the show. I love Tessa. But the writers seemed to think woman=victim. Many times over. It just struck me as if tho that maybe they like violence towards women or something. I'm a big Xena fan. I love strong warrior women in fiction. So for me personally, this was a big turn-off.

The fight between Duncan and Barnes was actually really good. In the end they did an intense shirtless Mac working out scene. They re-use this scene in other episodes. Mac has really bulked up. Bulging muscles but not as chiseled as in season one's 'Mountain Men.' Still really nice tho.

I found the story kind of weak. It was pretty obvious that Michael and Barnes were one and the same. Mac off on a goose chase at the asylum twice seemed like lazy writing to me. Tessa terrorized yet again, just made me frustrated and turned off. I gave the episode a 6/10.
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Charlie 1st appearance Warning: Spoilers
Ya like the Character Charlie, he added something to the show, also the dojo which becomes home. Funny stuff with the "invitation" and Richie's slight confusion as to what it is, turns into a who, and his shoulda seen a movie, to sitting there watching, maybe smirking too, course Mac "wins" sorta after all, a few hundred yrs experience, but does end up down once as Joe is back, some new building going up, graves and missing an executed body of Quentin Barns, a very nasty immortal, part of Macs past, and those who were involved are being killed, and or the surviving family members. Mac asks why Joe is telling him, he not a cop, and hey why doesn't Joe and company stop him...the we don't get involved, uh is as telling Mac bout it.

Another old friend, Micheal, comes along, says name Barns, as Barns killed Jeanette thinks he needs to take care of it, and the flashback, interesting, esp Mac "touching hand" of someone there who well needed it...Does end up calling Joe to get info, gets to the "father" who was at Barns execution too late, finds Micheal, has Mac promise to "take care of Barns" if he cant, Mac agrees.

Interesting though an immortal with split personality, this only epi with it, so very rare with immortals that wondering if Micheal/Barns only one, hmm was Micheal the "1st" personality and how was/did Barns appear? We never find out. Micheal did not know till the end, and did not want to live with it (actually don't think he could have as Barns was evil and Micheal wasn't) and Mac did promise to finish it, Micheal needed peace.

Love the shirtless AP...Joe lost a friend, did he not know Mac did too ? till Mac says to him I did too ? Hmmm Joe, knows all about Mac, just didn't put it together till Mac "I did too" my thinking, as Joe may know all or most but cant "feel" what it is like to be Mac..,
1 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed