add one point to two episodes episode, subtract one to two episodes episode ONLY...

1. The Magnificent Seven 10
2. The Kids Are All right 9 (-)
3. Bad Day at Black Rock 10
4. Sin City 11 (+)
5. Bedtime Stories 10
6. Red Sky at Morning 9 (-)
7. Fresh Blood 10
8. A Very Supernatural Christmas 10
9. Malleus Maleficarum 10
10. Dream a Little Dream of Me 10
11. Mystery Spot 10
12. Jus in Bello 10
13. Ghostfacers 11 (+)
14. Long-Distance Call 10
15. Time Is On My Side 10
16. No Rest for the Wicked 10

ELIINATED
16.