The Sheep Thief (2002) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
A professional and atmospheric short even if it is a little dull
bob the moo10 July 2004
A young boy gets caught stealing a sheep and is shaved of all his hair and branded with a mark on his forehead so that everyone will know that he is a thief and not to be trusted. Dumped in the desert, the thief covers his marking with a headscarf and goes to the nearest village where he is taken in by a trusting family in return for his work. However, has be actually changed or is he still the same thief at heart?

Continuing my self righteous rant that short films are not only worth seeing but are a great way of seeing future talent, comes this short film that was made by Kapadia a few years before he came to everyone's attention with his critically acclaimed 'The Warrior'. This film is set in the same sort of India that that was set as well as The Detour, which Kapadia also produced recently. Here we follow a young thief in a story that is quite slow and quite unsure of itself – is he trying to start over, or look for more chances to steal? It isn't made totally clear and is quite open and helps cover the fact that it is slow – it's a bit dull at times but it is thoughtful enough to cover this.

The cast are all pretty good and seem natural enough, although I'm not sure if they were all playing themselves or if they were actors brought in. Also the lack of dialogue means that they have less to convince with – perhaps making their task a little easier. The direction is good and the film feels very professional, looking good from start to finish. It may have been a little slow and bordering on being dull at one or more point but generally it is a very atmospheric and professional short film that has a real sense of place and time – worth seeing and yet another example of how short films are always worth seeing because you never know where the makers are going to be a few years hence.
5 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Way to go for Kapadia
Horst_In_Translation29 July 2016
Warning: Spoilers
"The Sheep Thief" is a 24-minute short film from the United Kingdom. It was written and directed by Asaf Kapadia back in 1997, which means it will have its 20th anniversary next year. Today, Kapadia is an Academy Award winner and considered one of the best documentary makers on the planet these days. I am always curious to see what stars have made or appeared in long before their big breakthrough. And in Kapadia's case, it was still live action and no documentary filmmaking, at least in terms of this film when he was in his 20s. The movie deals with foreign cultures and one reason may be the filmmaker's own cultural background. Anyway, I thought this was nothing too interesting to be honest and he had a long way to go to become who he is today, in terms of level and awards of course. If you still want to watch it, and also want to understand every single word, make sure you get subtitles. But you really aren't missing much if you skip this one. It never delivers on an emotional or story-telling level as it wants to. i give it a thumbs-down.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed